“…[12][13][14][15] Nevertheless, in both types of device, the attribution to oxygen vacancies is based on electrical data, optical spectra, and internal consistency. 4,6,11,13,[15][16][17][18] There has been no fully accepted chemical identification of the oxygen vacancy in HfO 2 by, say, electron spin resonance (ESR). [19][20][21] This situation differs from the oxygen vacancy in TiO 2 22 and contrasts strongly with the vast literature on the paramagnetic E 0 and P b centers in SiO 2 .…”