Problem framing of increased gender-based violence by national governments of Argentina and Spain during COVID-19: an interpretive policy analysis

Abstract

The COVID-19 pandemic resulted in mitigation efforts that put women at increased risk of gender-based violence. Stay-at-home requirements increased abuse at home. Early in the pandemic Spain and Argentina issued policies to address such violence at home. This policy analysis uses the ‘What’s the problem represented to be’ approach to shed light on the different assumptions, intentions and problem framings in both governments’ policy responses. Drawing on published policy documents we found both disparities and similarities in the way that gender-based violence is represented as a problem. Four key findings emerged; (1) gender-based violence is not clearly defined in the policies and the terminology has a partially (de)gendered discourse while focusing on female ‘victims’ of violence; (2) the role of men as perpetrators is ‘silenced’; (3) the problem construction weighs exclusively on the aftermath of the violence, and; (4) both countries address violence against LGBTI+ in different ways. Our recommendations are for policymakers to reconsider the focus of their policies in these respects to reduce the harm that naming and framing of gender-based violence can inflict. We recommend attention to the root causes of gender-based violence to result in a more holistic and sustainable approach in policy development.<br /><br/>Key messages<br/>The WPR approach to analysis of GBV policies during pandemics exposes underlying biases that avert attention from the root causes of GBV.<br/><br/>In order to reduce the prevalence of GBV, Argentina and Spain could redirect the focus of their COVID-19 policies away from women as ‘victims’ and towards the perpetrators of GBV.

“People as normal as possible”. Analysis of the construction of subjects in materials for the prevention of gender violence among teenagers in Spain

“…These forms of violence are present in the social debate and on the political agenda under the name intragender violence (Rodríguez Otero et al, 2017). The political and legal approach to this type of violence in Spain is separate from gender violence, understanding that “the genesis of this abuse does not lie in machismo” (Cremers & Hadley, 2022: 12) and framing it as a type of domestic violence (Rodríguez Otero et al, 2017). This construction can be interpreted as an attempt to recognise the existence violence in same‐sex couples without questioning the gender violence approach that strictly refers to the man‐aggressor vs woman‐victim binomial.…”