The
copper hydroxide ion, CuOH+, serves as the catalytic
core in several recently developed water-splitting catalysts, and
an understanding of its chemistry is critical to determining viable
catalytic mechanisms. In spite of its importance, the electronic structure
of this open-shell ion has remained ambiguous in the literature. In
particular, computed values for both the thermodynamics of hydration
and the vibrational signatures of the mono- and dihydrates have shown
prohibitively large errors compared to values from recent experimental
measurements. In this work, the source of this discrepancy is demonstrated
to be the propensity of this ion to exist between traditional Cu(I) and Cu(II) oxidation-state limits. The spin density
of the radical is accordingly shown to delocalize between the metal
center and surrounding ligands, and increasing the hydration serves
to exacerbate this behavior. Equation-of-motion coupled-cluster methods
demonstrated the requisite accuracy to resolve the thermodynamic discrepancies.
Such methods were also needed for spectral simulations, although the
latter also required a direct simulation of the role of the deuterium
“tag” molecules that are used in modern predissociation
spectroscopy experiments. This nominally benign tag molecule underwent
direct complexation with the open-valence metal ion, thereby forming
a species akin to known metal–H2 complexes and strongly
impacting the resulting spectrum. Thermal populations of this configuration
and other more traditional noncovalently bound isomers led to a considerable
broadening of the spectral lineshapes. Therefore, at least for the
CuOH+(H2O)0–2 hydrates, these
benchmark ions should be considered to be delocalized radical systems
with some degree of multireference character at equilibrium. They
also serve as a cautionary tale for the spectroscopy community, wherein
the role of the D2 tag is far from benign.