Print media portrayals of giving: exploring national ‘cultures of philanthropy’

Abstract

In their 2010 study drawing on 500 empirical philanthropy studies, Bekkers and Wiepking identified eight consistently significant giving mechanisms. The pilot study reported here extends what is known about one mechanism, values, as a giving driver, in particular considering how national cultural values apply to giving. Personal values are not formed in a vacuum. They are influenced by the wider culture and society: thus values have a socio‐cultural dimension. Accordingly, this pilot research draws on media theory and cultural studies work on national ethos to explore how these national cultural values interact with giving. A directed qualitative content analysis has been undertaken to compare US and Australian print media coverage about philanthropy. The two nations share an Anglo–Saxon orientation but differ significantly in national character and philanthropic activity. This study posits that a nation's media coverage about giving will reflect its national cultural ethos. This coverage can also shape personal values, thus implications exist for theory about the antecedents of personal giving values. Wider national values may drive or stifle giving, so this wider view of values as a driver has implications also for philanthropy promotion and fundraising. Copyright © 2011 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Philanthropy and social capital in Mexico

“…A growing body of empirical research, largely from developed nations, has demonstrated an important and positive relationship between social capital and philanthropic behavior, particularly making donations and volunteering (Putnam, , 116–133; Brooks, ; Brown & Ferris, ; Wang & Graddy, ; Wiepking & Maas, ; Bekkers, Völker, Van der Gaag, & Flap, ). Thus, one must appreciate the forms and expressions of social capital in order to understand the differences in philanthropic behavior (McDonald & Scaife ; Williams & Robinson, ).…”

Philanthropy in health professions education research: determinants of success

“…The combination of growing awareness of the need to fund‐raise and lack of a skill set with which to do so suggests an opportunity for educational development. The literature about fund‐raising as a general practice is a good place to start, including writing on the practice of fund‐raising, donor motivations, and the effects of engaging with donors . This literature can provide a solid conceptual foundation for learning; however, it is less suited to supporting practical skills.…”

Grantmaking in a Disorderly World: The Limits of Rationalism

“…Mimetic isomorphism happens when one organisation simply copies another, and partly explains foundations borrowing vocabularies and approaches from the dominant US foundation sector (McDonald and Scaife ) even if not required. Social media, international travel and conferences encourage mimetic isomorphism more as fashion and novelty than necessity.…”