Price Reactions to Rivals’ Local Channel Exits

Abstract

I n this paper, we study the effect of a firm's local channel exits on prices charged by incumbents remaining in the marketplace. Exits could result in higher prices due to tempered competition or lower prices due to reduced colocation or agglomeration benefits. The net effect of these two countervailing forces remains unknown. In addition, little is known about how this effect could change depending on incumbents' geographic locations. We address this research gap by examining new car price reactions by incumbent multiproduct automobile dealerships who experience the exit of a Chrysler dealership in their local markets. We find evidence that the competition effect exceeds the colocation effect: prices increase by about 1% ($318) following an exit relative to the price change in the absence of an exit. More important, we find that the price increase is lower at dealerships more proximate to the exiting dealership than dealerships farther away for the same set of cars available across these locations. This finding suggests differences in the extent of the two forces (competition and agglomeration) at different distances from the closed dealership. We assess the generalizability of our results by looking at the impact of GM's closure of Pontiac dealerships. Taken together, our results inform consumers, firms, and policymakers about possible implications of an exit.Data, as supplemental material, are available at http://dx.

Are Dealers Still Relevant? How Dealer Service Quality Impacts Manufacturer Success

“…Furthermore, our work informs the debate on the agglomeration effects of dealer co‐location (Benmelech et al. 2019, Murry and Zhou 2019, Ozturk, Venkataraman, and Chintagunta 2016). The basic theoretical models recommend avoiding co‐location to reduce competition (Baum and Haveman 1997).…”

Effects of advertising and R&D on spillovers from a rival’s bankruptcy

“…Second, we add to the literature that focuses on a firm's ex post strategic responses to a rival's bankruptcy to recognize the effects of ex ante investments. Such literature has shown that firms respond to a rival's bankruptcy by changing their product variety (Ren et al, 2019) and prices (Ozturk et al, 2016). Further, their sales can be affected by a rival's crisis (e.g., Giannetti & Srinivasan, 2021;Ozturk et al, 2019).…”

“…Second, when a firm files for bankruptcy, it has the potential to generate widespread spillovers to other firms in the industry. Research shows that one firm's bankruptcy can affect the sales and prices of other firms in the industry (Ozturk et al, 2016(Ozturk et al, , 2019. Research also shows that bankruptcy can affect the stock returns for other firms in the industry, and business examples are prevalent.…”

Distribution Channel Relationships in the Presence of Multimarket Contact

“…These studies have primarily focused on the influence of supply chain structures on the competitive actions of firms. Recent papers in this literature have investigated the impact of several supply chain structures on outcomes such as innovative output (Bellamy et al 2014), firms' financial performance (e.g., Wang et al 2021), retail prices (Ozturk et al 2016), and retail sales (Osadchiy et al 2016).…”