Prevalence of over-/misdiagnosis of asthma in patients referred to an allergy clinic

Abstract

MD (2015) Prevalence of over-/misdiagnosis of asthma in patients referred to an allergy clinic, Journal of Asthma, 52:9, 931-934, DOI: 10.3109/02770903.2015 Objective: Increasing asthma incidence may be due to an overall increase in asthma awareness by physicians, potentially resulting in overdiagnosis. One of the unique features of asthma is bronchial hyperresponsiveness, which can be assessed by methacholine bronchial challenge (MBC). Overdiagnosis may result in over-or mistreatment. The aims of this study were to describe the prevalence of the over-/misdiagnosis of asthma and the use of anti-asthmatic drugs in patients with asthma-like symptoms who had not yet undergone a respiratory function assessment to confirm the diagnosis of asthma. Methods: This was a retrospective study analyzing all MBCs performed by our Outpatient Allergy Clinic in a two-year period to confirm/ exclude the diagnosis of asthma in patients referred by general practitioners and complaining of asthma-like symptoms. Anti-asthmatic medications used by the patients until the MBC date were recorded. Results: 43.8% of the reviewed MBCs were positive and 37.4% of the patients with a positive MBC were previously taking anti-asthmatic drugs (568.8 ± 76.4 mcg mean beclomethasone equivalents), compared to 51.2% of those patients with a negative MBC (464.8 ± 57.8 mcg). No differences were found in the daily doses of inhaled corticosteroids or other anti-asthmatic drugs, or in the duration of treatment before the assessment of bronchial hyperresponsiveness. Conclusions: A sizeable percentage of subjects who reported physiciandiagnosed asthma had a negative MBC. Nevertheless, a greater proportion of negative MBC patients were taking anti-asthmatic drugs compared to those with a confirmed diagnosis of asthma, illustrating that the overdiagnosis of asthma may lead to over-and mistreatment of respiratory symptoms.

Reevaluation of Diagnosis in Adults With Physician-Diagnosed Asthma

“…Of 701 participants who entered into the study (mean [SD] age, 51 [16] years; 467 women [67%]), 64 withdrew early prior to establishment of a diagnosis and 24 could not undergo bronchial challenge testing for reasons described in Figure 2. Ultimately 613 participants completed the study assessment procedures and could be conclusively evaluated for a diagnosis of current asthma ( Figure 2 and Table 1).…”

The level of diagnostic assessment in severe asthma: A nationwide real-life study

“…A clinical diagnosis of asthma may be based solely on the presence of typical asthma symptoms, such as episodic breathlessness, chest tightness, wheezing or cough. However, a symptombased diagnosis is associated with a significant risk of overdiagnosis of asthma [10,12] leading to potential over-treatment.…”

Occupational lung diseases in Australia

“…Although seemingly self‐apparent, it is essential to accurately diagnose the lung condition present before establishing the diagnosis of an occupational lung disease. Even a common condition such as asthma is frequently misdiagnosed because of a failure to perform appropriate investigations 59 . Occupational factors should be considered in all patients with respiratory disease, but particular attention should be paid to new‐onset disease in a working age person, when there is uncertainty regarding the cause of a disease, or if an individual has worked or is working in a high‐risk industry.…”