Press Ideology as an Epistemological Connector between Framing Theory and Social Representations Theory: An Analysis of Violence and Drug Trafficking in the Mexican Press

Reyes-Sosa, Hiram; Larrañaga, Maider; Santos, Tânia R.; Perez-Marin, Luisa; Cuervo, Ángel Alberto Valdés

doi:10.1007/s12124-019-09498-z

Cited by 4 publications

(3 citation statements)

References 28 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Unclassified

Order By: Relevance

“…The Reinert method (using ALCESTE® or IRaMuTeQ) has been used in several studies across a wide range of research fields. For example, it has been used to study political speeches (Klein et Licata 2003;Schonhardt-Bailey, Yager, et Lahlou 2012), press ideology and scientific literature (Gonçalves Júnior et al 2021;Hamman, Anquetin, et Monicolle 2017;Reyes-Sosa et al 2020), nursing studies (Souza et al 2018Vioulac et al 2016) as well as in social and clinical psychology (Estienne et al 2019;Hochdorn et al 2018;Lamore et al 2020;Lelorain et al 2012;Robieux et al 2018). This method is of particular interest to study how a subject is discussed by individuals, groups or institutions.…”

Section: Introductionmentioning

confidence: 99%

What is the place of interpretation in text analysis? An example using ALCESTE® software

Montalescot,

Lamore,

Flahault

et al. 2024

Qualitative Research in Psychology

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Statistical text analyses appear at the borderline of quantitative and qualitative research, raising epistemological questions in the field. This paper focuses on a specific method of text analysis: the Reinert method. It aims to address the role of interpretation and subjectivity in the construction of the results using this kind of analysis. To this end, this manuscript presents a dual interpretation of a same corpus and software outputs highlighting the convergences and divergences in both researchers' interpretations. It discusses how the use of statistics on qualitative data may provide a false sense of objectivity and sweep the questions of interpretation and epistemology away. Finally, it offers clear guidelines regarding individual and dual interpretation to those who wish to start using the Reinert method. We argue that this type of analysis is adaptable and can be applied across a variety of epistemological stances and research questions.

show abstract

Section: Introductionmentioning

confidence: 99%

What is the place of interpretation in text analysis? An example using ALCESTE® software

Montalescot,

Lamore,

Flahault

et al. 2024

Qualitative Research in Psychology

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…Por ser uma técnica projetiva possibilita a/ao pesquisadora(dor) estruturar as respostas apresentadas a partir de um termo e/ou expressão indutor(a), em situações de evocação espontânea e imediata, bem como a identificação dos possíveis universos semânticos e consensuais de um determinado grupo, relacionados a um respectivo estímulo (11) . O uso dessa técnica tem sido amplamente utilizada com a TRS em pesquisas nacionais na área da Enfermagem (13,14) , bem como, tem atuado como um importante apoio a estudos nacionais (15) e internacionais (16,17) em psicologia, ajudando a entender o assunto como um constituído por interações sociais com outros sujeitos.…”

Section: Métodosunclassified

Na rua, a droga é destruição e curtição: um estudo em representações sociais

Campos

Oliveira

Jesus

et al. 2020

Rev. Eletr. Enferm.

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Este estudo objetiva analisar a estrutura das representações sociais de pessoas em situação de rua sobre drogas. Pesquisa qualitativa, com 158 pessoas em situação de rua, que responderam ao Teste de Associação Livre de Palavras, com o estímulo “drogas” de novembro/2017 a janeiro/2018. Os dados foram processados por dois softwares que permitiram análise fundamentada na Teoria das Representações Sociais. Nas representações gráficas geradas pelos softwares, os termos “destruição”, “coisa ruim”, “tristeza” sinalizam uma conotação negativa sobre as drogas em contraponto ao termo “curtição” que revela o uso como ação que promove prazer, sobrevivência, relacionada ao contexto da rua. Para o grupo investigado, as drogas representam elemento de sobrevivência, que podem potencializar outras vulnerabilidades. Destaca-se a importância da Estratégia de Redução de Danos no cuidado às pessoas em situação de rua, pela possibilidade desta considerar o sujeito, suas representações e especificidades. Descritores: Drogas; Pessoas em Situação de Rua; Associação Livre; Vulnerabilidade Social.

show abstract

“…1.It should be noted that this newspaper has a section called “police,” which specializes in violent events. Furthermore, based on previous studies, it has been shown that this newspaper presents its news in two types of category: human interest (sensationalist) and morality (Reyes-Sosa et al, 2020). …”

mentioning

confidence: 99%

Rape Culture, Revictimization, and Social Representations: Images and Discourses on Sexual and Violent Crimes in the Digital Sphere in Mexico

Reyes-Sosa

Martínez-Cueva

Mondragón

2022

J Interpers Violence

Self Cite

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

The digital sphere has become a space in which misogyny-laden discourses are constantly presented. In fact, in Mexico persists a rape culture that justifies violent acts against women and blames the victims of the crimes through social opinions. The present study proposed an approach based on the Theory of Social Representations. In this sense, this study aimed to analyze the discourses that emerge in the digital sphere when users give their opinion on five types of crimes against women: femicide, rape, enforced disappearance, abuse, and sexual harassment. The results revealed that there are four types of discourse (representations) framed within rape culture: disbelief of rape, blaming the victim, revictimization, and disempowering women. It is concluded that Mexican society maintains a representation that stereotypes and devalues the image of women, which allows us to understand the aggressions that women suffer in their daily lives.

show abstract

Press Ideology as an Epistemological Connector between Framing Theory and Social Representations Theory: An Analysis of Violence and Drug Trafficking in the Mexican Press

Cited by 4 publications

References 28 publications

What is the place of interpretation in text analysis? An example using ALCESTE® software

What is the place of interpretation in text analysis? An example using ALCESTE® software

Na rua, a droga é destruição e curtição: um estudo em representações sociais

Rape Culture, Revictimization, and Social Representations: Images and Discourses on Sexual and Violent Crimes in the Digital Sphere in Mexico

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About