Predictions, role of interventions and effects of a historic national lockdown in India’s response to the COVID-19 pandemic: data science call to arms

Abstract

Importance: India has taken strong and early public health measures for arresting the spread of the COVID-19 epidemic. With only 536 COVID-19 cases and 11 fatalities, India -a democracy of 1.34 billion people -took the historic decision of a 21-day national lockdown on March 25. The lockdown was further extended to May 3rd, soon after the analysis of this paper was completed.Objective: To study the short-and long-term impact of an initial 21-day lockdown on the total number of COVID-19 cases in India compared to other less severe non-pharmaceutical interventions using epidemiological forecasting models and Bayesian estimation algorithms; to compare effects of hypothetical durations of lockdown from an epidemiological perspective; to study alternative explanations for slower growth rate of the virus outbreak in India, including exploring the association of the number of cases and average monthly temperature; and finally, to outline the pivotal role of reliable and transparent data, reproducible data science methods, tools and products as we reopen the country and prepare for a post lock-down phase of the pandemic. Design, Setting, and Participants:We use the daily data on the number of COVID-19 cases, of recovered and of deaths from March 1 until April 7, 2020 from the 2019 Novel Coronavirus Visual Dashboard operated by the Johns Hopkins University Center for Systems Science and Engineering (JHU CSSE). Additionally, we use COVID-19 incidence counts data from Kaggle and the monthly average temperature of major cities across the world from Wikipedia. Main Outcome and Measures:The current time-series data on daily proportions of cases and removed (recovered and death combined) from India are analyzed using an extended version of the standard SIR (susceptible, infected, and removed) model. The eSIR model incorporates timevarying transmission rates that help us predict the effect of lockdown compared to other hypothetical interventions on the number of cases at future time points. A Markov Chain Monte Carlo implementation of this model provided predicted proportions of the cases at future time points along with credible intervals (CI). Results:Our predicted cumulative number of COVID-19 cases in India on April 30 assuming a 1-week delay in people's adherence to a 21-day lockdown (March 25 -April 14) and a gradual, moderate resumption of daily activities after April 14 is 9,181 with upper 95% CI of 72,245. In comparison, the predicted cumulative number of cases under "no intervention" and "social distancing and travel bans without lockdown" are 358 thousand and 46 thousand (upper 95% CI of nearly 2.3 million and 0.3 million) respectively. An effective lockdown can prevent roughly 343 thousand (upper 95% CI 1.8 million) and 2.4 million (upper 95% CI 38.4 million) COVID-19 cases nationwide compared to social distancing alone by May 15 and June 15, respectively. When comparing a 21-day lockdown with a hypothetical lockdown of longer duration, we find that 28-, 42-, and 56-day lockdowns can approximately prevent 238 thousan...

Assessment of Air Quality Changes in the Four Metropolitan Cities of India during COVID-19 Pandemic Lockdown

“…The environment particulate, PM 10 particles may play crucial role in disease transmission by carrying the COVID viruses (Setti et al, 2020). It has been estimated that lockdown measures in India have been responsible for much lower cases than estimated of COVID-19 (Koshy, 2020;Ray et al, 2020). Along with decrease in air pollution, lockdown implementation has also helped in lowering down the basic reproduction number (R 0 ) of the disease by reducing the contact rate.…”

Forecasting Transmission Dynamics of COVID-19 Epidemic in India Under Various Containment Measures- A Time-Dependent State-Space SIR Approach

“…The fact that instead of using pre-specified modifier for each phase, we have estimated phase-specific modifiers from the observed data improves our chances of obtaining more reliable estimates of transmission rate and R 0 as compared to other recent studies on India, like Ray et al (2020). Use of lower than true values of modifiers may lead to over-estimation of transmission rate and vice-versa.…”

“…To account for variations in transmission rate of the infection due to the implementation of various containment protocols, we propose to implement a time-dependent state-space SIR model to the observed data from India. Instead of taking a pre-specified step function modifier like Ray et al (2020), we propose a time-series SIR based approach to estimate the phase-wise transmission modifiers. Modifier functions, both step and exponential, are estimated using the daily prevalence data reported in India from 2 nd March, 2020 to 30 th April, 2020.…”

A machine learning based forecast model for the COVID-19 pandemic and investigation of the impact of government intervention on COVID-19 transmission in China

“…Baidu, established in 2000, is a Chinese technology company specializing in its search engine, Internet services, and artificial intelligence The city lockdown policy implemented in China is already known to be a highly important factor in controlling the spread of 2019-nCoV in China (Zhang et al, 2020). Some previous researches have perceived the fruitfulness of travel restriction in controlling the spread of COVID-19 (Fanelli and Piazza, 2020, Ray et al, 2020, Sardar et al, 2020. As distinguished from previous studies, this paper combines the BPNN model with Baidu Migration LBS data and considers the impact of intracity and inter-city travel on the spread of the disease, so it has specific promotion and generalization ability.…”