Editorial Comment to Prediction models for the viability of pulmonary metastatic lesions after chemotherapy in nonseminomatous germ cell tumorsIn the present study, Tsunezuka et al. 1 operated on 40 patients and 326 pulmonary lesions after chemotherapy for the germ cell tumor. This is the first report with many specimens, precise histological examination and clinical background that can predict the viability in a lung specimen. Histological examinations showed 73 (22%) viable cells, which include 46 (16%) teratomas and/or 37 (11%) residual cancer cells, whereas the other 253 (78%) lesions were necrosis or fibrosis. The findings that the cancer cells mainly composed of yolk sac tumor are very interesting and have never been reported before.The authors carried out multivariate analyses and showed that the predictors associated with cancer cells were as follows: (i) elevated tumor markers; (ii) multiregimen chemotherapy; (iii) increased tumor size 6 months before surgery; and (iv) yolk sac tumor in the primary lesion. Among these predictors, elevated tumor markers and increased tumor size before operation are common sense among urologists. Operation under these circumstances is so-called "desperation surgery," which usually results in a poor outcome. What we really wanted to know is the factors that will predict a better prognostic outcome, even in the desperation surgery; however, they did not discuss this issue in this article. According to their findings, what should we do in the clinical practice? Whether they do not recommend pulmonary metastasectomy in the high-risk group, or even in the high-risk group, is it still worth carrying out desperation surgery? If they can provide us with such information, it would be really useful for prioritizing pulmonary metastasectomy. Another limitation of this study is that they did not show the level of positivity of tumor markers. If the human chorionic gonadotropin (HCG) elevation is slight (e.g. 1-5 mIU/mL), they might be false positive or decrease to a normal level spontaneously. Further-more, the authors measured free-beta HCG (ng/mL), that is more likely to show false positives than the total HCG (mIU/ mL). In the previous study about salvage surgery with elevated tumor markers, patients with elevated alpha fetoprotein alone (i.e. normal HCG levels) were shown to have a better prognosis. 2 However, in that study, only a small number (n = 2) of lung metastasis were included. When the authors provide their data using proper HCG measurement, they might be able to show a different strategy in lung metastasis.Despite these limitations, the authors' analysis of pulmonary metastasectomy in the treatment of germ cell tumor is the first report so far, and provides us with a great deal of precious consideration in this lesion. Further analysis including long-term prognosis will be expected. References 1 Tsunezuka H, Nakamura T, Fujikawa K et al. Prediction models for the viability of pulmonary metastatic lesions after chemotherapy in nonseminomatous germ cell tumors. Int. J. Uro...