Predicting potential distributions of invasive species: where to go from here?

Abstract

Aim There has been considerable recent interest in modelling the potential distributions of invasive species. However, research has developed in two opposite directions: the first, focusing on screening, utilizes phenomenological models; the second, focusing on predictions of invasion dynamics, utilizes mechanistic models. Here, we present hybrid modelling as an approach to bridge the gap and to integrate the advantages of both research directions. Location Global. Methods First, we briefly summarize the characteristics and limitations of both approaches (screening vs. understanding). Then, we review the recent developments of hybrid models, discuss their current problems and offer suggestions to improve them. Results Generally, hybrid models are able to combine the advantages of currently used phenomenological and mechanistic approaches. Main challenges in building hybrid models are the choices of the appropriate degree of detail and efficiency and the decision on how to connect the different sub‐models. Given these challenges, we discuss the links between the phenomenological and the mechanistic model parameters, the underlying concepts of fundamental and realized niches and the problem of feedback loops between population dynamics and environmental factors. Main conclusions Once the above challenges have been addressed and the necessary framework has been developed, hybrid models will provide outstanding tools for overcoming past limitations and will provide the means to make reliable and robust predictions of the potential distribution of invasive species, their population dynamics and the potential outcomes of the overall invasion process.

Predicting the spread of marine species introduced by global shipping

“…Models can help to improve mitigation strategies by the determination of hot spots of biological invasions, the determination of high-risk pathways, and the identification of species likely to arrive next. Several studies have tried to predict the likelihood of new invasions (10,13,(25)(26)(27)(28); however, the common paucity of model validations hampers the assessment of the quality of model predictions and their comparison between different approaches. Here, we provide a robust approach for the validation of colonization models, simulating the spread of alien species, which may serve as an example for other models and taxonomic groups.…”

Uses and misuses of bioclimatic envelope modeling

“…In effect, an incomplete grasp of fundamental concepts underpinning the models leads to significant misapplications and misinterpretations in significant portions of the literature. Although improvements in both the data and the modeling methods that are available , Chevin et al 2010, Gallien et al 2010 will have some effect, the usefulness of these models is highly contingent on their appropriate use; hence, the situation will improve most with better awareness of the conceptual bases and consequent strengths and limitations of these models.…”

Improving plant functional groups for dynamic models of biodiversity: at the crossroads between functional and community ecology

“…1) have been developed. They usually combine existing process-based models to depict successional dynamics and/or dispersal, with habitat suitability models to constrain species distribution by abiotic factors (Gallien et al, 2010). In order to involve a sufficient number of species to represent the whole vegetation diversity at regional scale, hybridDVMs require modeling entities of intermediate complexity between species level and broad PFT classifications.…”