Practical Experience and On-Farm Research with Weed Management in an Iowa Ridge Tillage-Based System

Abstract

The weed management system of most producers is complex and represents the summation of years of experience and informal observation. The ridge tillage, row crop system described here is especially complex because it seeks to use cultural and mechanical weed controls in preference to herbicides. Both experience and formal experimentation have contributed to the development of the system. Fundamental are two working hypotheses that may appear counterintuitive: (i) that tillage can stimulate weeds and (ii) that weeds can be used to control other weeds. Results of on‐farm trials on the Thompson farm have supported these hypotheses. Additional on‐farm trials have pointed toward conditions in which rotary hoe tillage can be used to best effect to eliminate weeds. Results of 51 replicated on‐farm trials by Practical Farmers of Iowa (PFI), an organization that generates and shares information about profitable, environmentally sound farming methods, showed that ridge tillage without herbicides is an effective and economical system for weed management and row crop production. Experience gained developing this alternative weed management system can be summarized in guidelines applying, respectively, to the overall system, the planter, the rotary hoe, first cultivation, and second (lay‐by) cultivation. Research Question Can weeds be effectively managed in a row crop system that relies primarily on cultural and mechanical techniques? Moreover, would such a weed management system be economical and could it be compatible with cover crops and residue management practices that reduce soil erosion? Literature Summary Observation: Farmers who do not use primary tillage frequently see a great increase in weeds where endrows are disked. Research has shown that ridge tillage avoids this kind of soil disruption and the stimulatory effect it has on some weeds. Ridge‐till also mechanically displaces weed seeds from the row at planting. Observation: Highway widening exposed soil along several fields; the ditches taken out of fields where herbicides had been used and only row crops were raised grew a solid stand of velvetleaf. The ditches from fields in a corn‐soybean‐corn‐oatkay‐hay rotation, where herbicides had not been used for the previous 18 yr did not have velvetleaf. While the crop rotation difference may have affected the weed seed bank in the two kinds of fields, crop history showed a seed reserve in both. Research has shown that plants can have chemically mediated suppressive effects on other plants, the phenomenon termed allelopathy. Could allelopathy be responsible for the observed difference in velvetleaf along the road cut? Study Description Observation and experimentation have led to an alternative weed management system in which herbicides have not been used for 18 yr. Important elements of the system are: ridge tillage, the rotary hoe, a weed suppressive and allelopathic cover crop of rye drilled just on the ridge, and a diverse crop rotation to break weed cycles. Replicated on‐farm experiments have contributed to the ev...

Focus on ecological weed management: what is hindering adoption?

“…Particularly on‐farm research programs that last for at least a number of years (e.g. Exner et al. , 1996) and crop rotational studies on experimental farms (e.g.…”

Integration of soil, crop and weed management in low‐external‐input farming systems

“…To prevent subsequent stimulation of weed emergence by secondary tillage, this method may require the foregoing of soil disturbance after residue incorporation. Secondly, ridge-tillage equipment and other specialized machinery can be used to clear allelopathic residues from bands where crops seeds are being sown (Exner et al, 1996). Finally, small-seeded weed and crop species appear to be especially susceptible to allelochemicals, whereas large-seeded species appear to be relatively insensitive (Putnam & DeFrank, 1983).…”

Strategies and tactics for herbicide use reduction in field crops in Canada: A review

“…The Practical Farmers of Iowa represent another example of collaborative research, initiated by farmers. Research by farmers in this group has been published in peer-reviewed journals and is an example of long-term customization of alternative weed management strategies to particular farm situations (Rossman 1994;Exner et al 1996).…”