Ponds, Power and Institutions: The Everyday Governance of Accessing Urban Water Bodies in a Small Bengali City

Abstract

While researchers in the growing field of urban political ecology have given significant attention to the fragmented hydroscape that characterizes access to drinking water in the global South, so far the (re)production of other urban waters and its related power relations have been underexplored. This article seeks to contribute to filling this gap by exploring the everyday negotiations over access to urban water bodies, in particular ponds. These are understood as a composite resource that is simultaneously water, land and public space. This analysis draws on a case study from a small city in West Bengal, India, and is based primarily on data from open interviews with different actors with a stake in urban ponds. The article demonstrates that in a context of ambiguity of the statutory governance regime and fragmented control, the (re)production of the pondscape is embedded within complex relationships of power whereby social marginalization can be offset at least momentarily by local institutions such as neighbourhood clubs and political parties.

Water Brokers: Exploring Urban Water Governance through the Practices of Tanker Water Supply in Accra

“…Although not formally endorsed, they are referred to in several policy documents, including the recently introduced National Drinking Water Quality Management Framework that was published in 2015. The framework "recommends implementation of water safety plans for vending water supply that incorporate all components of water vending, including sources, methods of abstraction and transport" [29]. It shifts the responsibility of implementing and operationalizing the safety plans to tanker drivers and vendors and of monitoring and reporting to regulatory organizations (e.g., MMDAs or PURC) in the case vendors are registered or have a contract with the utility and conduct independent surveillance.…”

Introduction. Environmental Politics in Urban India

“…Global financial flows through the Rotary Foundation and party politics play crucial roles in this production of uneven socio-nature. Cornea, Zimmer and Véron (2016) also highlight the role of party politics in shaping access to urban ponds in a small town in West Bengal. There, everyday access is achieved by marginalised groups through diverse strategies that include: affiliation to political parties and/or neighbourhood clubs, often translated into unspecified threats; moral norms of support for the poor; and the (in)visibility of specific ponds within bureaucratic processes.…”

Intersectionality challenges for the co-production of urban services: notes for a theoretical and methodological agenda

“…(54) One key contribution from this body of work is that it highlights that situated power relations need to be understood in context and their analysis cannot be easily generalized across contexts of service provision. (55) One key insight from the political ecology tradition is that dominant knowledge structures, mostly developed in the West, fail to capture the complexity of delivery systems already in place. Those knowledge systems thus preclude emancipatory strategies of urban development in lower income countries.…”