Politics-as-usual on trial: regional anti-corruption campaigns in Indonesia

Abstract

This article explores to what extent to local pro-reform actors matter in Indonesia through the prism of anti-corruption campaigns in the country's regions. I argue that the rash of anti-corruption campaigns and related trials involving legislative members, especially from mid-2004 onward, can be attributed neither to the resources lavished on anti-corruption organizations based in Jakarta, nor to the popularity of President Yudhoyono's anti-corruption rhetoric. Instead, it can be traced to a particular anti-corruption campaign that began in earnest in 2002 in Padang, West Sumatra. Using a multi-dimensional approach, a small group of activists relentlessly pursued their newly elected provincial legislators to be accountable to their democratic mandates and as important, to respect the rule of law pursuant to new national anti-corruption legislation. The guilty verdicts of May 2004 galvanized similar groups across the country to investigate their respective legislative bodies. This exemplary case of societal accountability also demonstrated the leverage activists can gain over local politicians when they forge coalitions with other elite actors, especially those in Jakarta. I further explore two anti-corruption cases in the province of West Kalimantan to place post-Padang developments in their proper perspective. If hopes were raised that regional anti-corruption movements-based on the Padang model-might accomplish more than sensational trials but help consolidate democracy at the regional level by holding elected officials accountable, these two examples show how fleeting these expectations might be.

From User Fees to Fee Free: The Politics of Realising Universal Free Basic Education in Indonesia

“…Overall, the effect was to modestly increase the scope for pro-poor reform while ensuring that it did not go so far as to disrupt the existing political and social order (Davidson, 2007;Rosser et al, 2005).…”

Dilemmas of democratic consolidation in Indonesia

“…13 This fact necessitates that reform -if at all -must come from the top and from the centre. Accordingly, encouraging developments in the regions -for example, the high number successful prosecutions of regional legislators for the misappropriation of budgetary funds (Davidson 2007) -can be effectively contained by the center, preventing 'uncontrollable' contagion effects that might snare a large swath of central government officials (and legislators).…”

Civic Organisations and Governance Reform in Indonesian Cities

“…Several scholars have deliberated on the question of 'right' governance, focusing on the weaknesses of transferring external concepts of governance into Indonesian regional politics (Hadiz, 2004), the persistence of irrational elements in regional bureaucracy (Bubandt, 2006), and the diffi culties involved in replicating in other regions the success story of anti-corruption movements in Padang, West Sumatra (Davidson, 2007). Others look at on the role of regional civic organisations in the process of democratisation, with focus on their strategies, targeted parties and outcomes (Ganie-Rochman, 2002;Demos, 2003;Suharko, 2005).…”