Pivotal debates and controversies on the structure and function of the avian respiratory system: setting the record straight

Abstract

Among the extant air-breathing vertebrates, the avian respiratory system is structurally the most complex and functionally the most efficient gas exchanger. Having been investigated for over four centuries, some aspects of its biology have been extremely challenging and highly contentious and others still remain unresolved. Here, while assessing the most recent findings, four notable aspects of the structure and function of the avian respiratory system are examined critically to highlight the questions, speculations, controversies and debates that have arisen from past research. The innovative techniques and experiments that were performed to answer particular research questions are emphasised. The features that are outlined here concern the arrangement of the airways, the path followed by the inspired air, structural features of the lung and the air and blood capillaries, and the level of cellular defence in the avian respiratory system. Hitherto, based on association with the proven efficiency of naturally evolved and human-made counter-current exchange systems rather than on definite experimental evidence, a counter-current gas exchange system was suggested to exist in the avian respiratory system and was used to explain its exceptional efficiency. However, by means of an elegant experiment in which the direction of the air-flow in the lung was reversed, a cross-current system was shown to be in operation instead. Studies of the arrangement of the airways and the blood vessels corroborated the existence of a cross-current system in the avian lung. While the avian respiratory system is ventilated tidally, like most other invaginated gas exchangers, the lung, specifically the paleopulmonic parabronchi, is ventilated unidirectionally and continuously in a caudocranial (back-to-front) direction by synchronized actions of the air sacs. The path followed by the inspired air in the lung-air sac system is now known to be controlled by a mechanism of aerodynamic valving and not by anatomical valves or sphincters, as was previously supposed. The structural strength of the air and blood capillaries is derived from: the interdependence between the air and blood capillaries; a tethering effect between the closely entwined respiratory units; the presence of epithelial-epithelial cell connections (retinacula or cross-bridges) that join the blood capillaries while separating the air capillaries; the abundance and intricate arrangement of the connective tissue elements, i.e. collagen, elastin, and smooth muscle fibres; the presence of type-IV collagen, especially in the basement membranes of the blood-gas barrier and the epithelial-epithelial cell connections; and a putative tensegrity state in the lung. Notwithstanding the paucity of free surface pulmonary macrophages, the respiratory surface of the avian lung is well protected from pathogens and particulates by an assortment of highly efficient phagocytic cells. In commercial poultry production, instead of weak pulmonary cellular defence, stressful husbandry practices such a...

Anatomy, ontogeny, and evolution of the archosaurian respiratory system: A case study on Alligator mississippiensis and Struthio camelus

“…Additionally, the majority of the quantitative metrics obtained from the bronchial tree in the alligators were collected from the proximal portion which is cartilaginous in nature (CVB, L, D2–3 and associated PB measures) and the avian bronchial tree is immobilized and thus less flexible than other pulmonary tissues (e.g. Maina, 2006b; Maina, 2017).…”

The alveolar gas equation: do lessons from WW2 research into high flying pilots provide insights into the adaptation to high altitude flight in birds?

“…For example, gas flow through the paleopulmonic parabronchi is unidirectional, but it is believed to be tidal within neo-pulmonic parabronchi (Weidner W, 2011). Similarly, pulmonary capillary blood flows perpendicularly to gas flow within the parabronchi but it runs directly counter to gas flow within the air capillaries (Maina J, 2017). Whether the resulting gas exchange is best described as cross-current, counter-current, or a mixture of both, was debated at length in earlier literature (Scheid P, et al, 1972).…”

“…Given these similarities, this study argues that lessons learned from over 150 years of research into the physiology of high altitude in humans have relevance for the understanding of the adaptation to hypobaric hypoxia in birds -particularly in the application of the alveolar gas equation (AGE) to birds. The basic hypothesis of this paper is that the long-standing theory of avian gas exchange based on multicapillary serial arterialization (Maina J, 2017), is incorrect because it does not include the effect of CO2 at the level of gas exchange.…”

Determining Image Opacity in Broiler Respiratory Radiographic Using ImageJ and Ansel Adam’s Zone System

“…The primary bronchi then divide further into the secondary bronchi (consisting of four kinds in the form of mediodorsal, medioventral, lateroventral, laterodorsal) to the parabronchi (tertiary bronchus) either paleopulmonic or neopulmonic. Nine air sacs are consisting of one interclavicular, two cervicals, two cranial thoracics, and two caudal thoracics, and two abdominal (Schmidt and Wild 2014;Powell 2015;Maina 2016). Therefore, it is challenging to extrapolate personal data of chicken respiratory systems as there are different characteristics.…”