Physical growth and ethnic inequality in New Zealand prisons, 1840–1975

Abstract

The British colonization of New Zealand after 1840 was marked by an unusual concern compared to other settler colonies for incorporating the indigenous population Māori population into the new society. But despite a continuing political rhetoric of protection and sovereignty Māori have historically had lower living standards and, since the 1920s, higher rates of incarceration than European-descended New Zealanders (Pākehā). In this paper we examine differences between Māori and Pākehā over 130 years using prison records. Aggregate data from the Ministry of Justice show long-term change and differences in incarceration rates. Using a dataset of all extant registers of men entering New Zealand prisons we show change over time in convictions and in height. The adult statures of Māori and Pākehā were similar for men born before 1900 but marked differences emerged among cohorts born during the twentieth century. By World War II the gap in adult stature widened to around 3 cm, before narrowing for men born after World War II. Periods of divergence in stature are paralleled by divergence in fertility and indicators of family size, suggesting the possibility that increasing fertility stressed the economic situation of Māori families. The prison evidence suggests that inequalities in ‘net nutrition’ between Māori and Pākehā are long-standing but not unchanging, indeed they increased for cohorts born into the early 20th century. A subset of the data describing adolescents confirms that among those born after 1945 the ethnic differential was already visible by the age of 16 years.

‘Indians are the Majority of the Prisoners’? Historical Variations in Incarceration Rates for Indigenous Women and Men in British Columbia

“…After the First World War, Māori were significantly more likely to enter prison and to be convicted in the magistrate's court. This evidence suggests that per capita Māori incarceration overtook that of the white settlers, on average across New Zealand, about the end of the First World War (Inwood, Oxley and Roberts 2015). Thus, the Māori followed a trajectory similar to that of Indigenous people in British Columbia, possibly with a slightly earlier transition to the modern experience of relatively high and rising incarceration.…”

Height of Male Prisoners in Santiago de Chile during the Nitrate Era: The Penalty of being Unskilled, Illiterate, Illegitimate and Mapuche

“…Prison records have been used for biological and medical research for over a century in countries such as Britain and the United States [ 34 ]. They have also been widely used in anthropometric studies in particular for many countries, including Britain, Ireland, the US and New Zealand (e.g., [ 35 , 36 , 37 , 38 ]).…”

Black living standards in South Africa before democracy: New evidence from height

“…Examples of different ethnic groups converging in heights as socio-economic conditions improve comes from the experience of Māori and white (Pākehā) New Zealanders since World War II. 57 While the height gap between the Māori and whites was 3 cm for those born during World War II, this gap disappeared for children born during the 1980s as a result of economic growth and better public health and other social policies. These and other population-level anthropometric studies point to the possibility, at least in the long run, for convergence of stature among different ethnic groups in South Africa.…”