Pediatrician Beliefs About Spirituality and Religion in Medicine: Associations With Clinical Practice

Abstract

ABSTRACT. Objectives. Identify pediatrician (faculty and resident) beliefs about spirituality and religion (SR) in medicine and the relationship of those beliefs to SR behavior and experiences in clinical practice.Methods. A self-report questionnaire was administered to full-time pediatric faculty (N ‫؍‬ 65) and residents (N ‫؍‬ 56) of an urban children's hospital affiliated with a school of medicine. The response rate was 70.8% among faculty (n ‫؍‬ 46) and 78.6% among residents (n ‫؍‬ 44). Respondents indicated the extent of their SR inquiry and the frequency of their SR experiences (requests by patients or families to discuss SR or pray), routinely and during health crisis, and rated 19 belief statements about SR in pediatrics.Results. Few pediatricians routinely ask about SR issues. Faculty were more likely than residents to ask about religious affiliation, whereas residents were more likely to be asked to pray during health crises, to believe that SR has health relevance, and to perceive pediatrician-initiated prayer as appropriate. Composite scores indicated that physicians who did not expect negative patient reactions to SR inquiry and prayer, who believed more strongly that SR is relevant to pediatric outcomes, and who felt more capable with SR inquiry were more likely to engage in SR inquiry and to experience SR requests.Conclusions. Pediatrician beliefs with respect to health relevance of SR, patient reactions to SR inquiry, and physician capabilities regarding SR in the clinic are strongly related to their clinical practice concerning SR inquiry and experiences. Correction of physician misperceptions about SR issues and incorporation of religious sensitivity into physician training may remove barriers to both patient and physician SR inquiry. Pediatrics 2003;111:e227-e235. URL: http://www.pediatrics.org/cgi/ content/full/111/3/e227; pediatrics, religion in medicine, physician's role, attitude of health personnel, internship and residency, medical education.ABBREVIATIONS. SR, "spiritual and religious" or "spirituality and religion"; SD, standard deviation.

Observations of Muslim Physicians Regarding the Influence of Religion on Health and Their Clinical Approach

“…This finding is in agreement with data from Armbruster et al (2003), who showed that paediatric residents were less likely to enquire about religious beliefs in comparison to faculty physicians (24.4% vs. 6.8%), highlighting the importance of training in how to have such discussions.…”

“…Because there is no other study in the literature that measures the same study variables in a Muslim population, the sample size was determined based on previously published questionnaire-based surveys of religiosity among physicians in other populations (Luckhaupt et al 2005;Ellis et al 1999;Armbruster et al 2003). A convenient sample size was estimated to be two hundred.…”

Religion/Spirituality and Adolescent Psychiatric Symptoms: A Review

“…Clinicians have already begun to use formal ''spiritual history'' templates developed for incorporation into the clinical encounter [63]. Although one study found that while only one fourth of pediatric attending physicians and 7% of pediatric residents routinely inquired about patient/family religious issues, nearly three quarters of these attending physicians and 90% of these residents felt that religious beliefs positively impact health, and roughly 90% of both groups felt religious issues were relevant to pediatric medicine [64]. The connections demonstrated between mental health and religion/spirituality call for clinicians to get to know about the role of religion/spirituality in their patients' lives.…”

A Survey of Complementary and Alternative Medicine (CAM) Awareness Among Neurosurgeons in Washington State

“…Spirituality, religion, and prayer can be topics avoided in medicine, especially by conventionally trained physicians who do not wish to offend their patients or are uncomfortable discussing this topic. 11 However, for millennia, religion and healing have been intertwined. Patients often pray for their own health and the health of others.…”