Paternalism and autonomy: views of patients and providers in a transitional (post-communist) country

Abstract

BackgroundPatient autonomy is a fundamental, yet challenging, principle of professional medical ethics. The idea that individual patients should have the freedom to make choices about their lives, including medical matters, has become increasingly prominent in current literature. However, this has not always been the case, especially in communist countries where paternalistic attitudes have been interwoven into all relationships including medical ones. Patients’ expectations and the role of the doctor in the patient-physician relationship are changing. Croatia, as a transitional country, is currently undergoing this particular process.MethodsQualitative research was conducted by means of six focus group discussions held in the years 2012 and 2013 in Croatia. Focus groups were held separately with each of the following: first year and final (6th) year medical students, physicians engaged in medical ethics education, physicians practicing in a clinical hospital, family medicine residents and individuals representing patients with chronic disease. This research specifically addresses issues related to patient autonomy, in particular, the principles of truth telling, confidentiality, and informed consent. All focus group discussions were audio taped and then transcribed verbatim and systematized according to acknowledged qualitative analysis methods.Results and discussionPatient autonomy is much more than a simple notion defined as the patient’s right to make treatment decisions independently. It has to be understood in context of the broader socio-cultural setting. At present, both patients and medical doctors in Croatia are increasingly appreciating the importance of promoting the principle of autonomy in medical decision-making. However, the current views of medical students, physicians and patients reveal inconsistencies.Conclusions Knowing how to respect the various facets of patients’ autonomy should be part of physician’s professional duties, and also be reflected in his or her core clinical competencies. For this reason greater importance should be dedicated to patient autonomy issues in medical education in Croatia.

Causal Attribution and Coping Maxims Differences between Immigrants and Non-Immigrants Suffering from Back Pain in Switzerland

“…Part of the explanation might lie in the fact that most of the participants with an immigration background in this study came from countries that until fairly recently still had a very paternalistic vision on healthcare, thus ascribing the physician a very important role in treating illnesses [49, 50]. The study further identified that Albanian-speakers were more likely to attribute their back pain to “Burden and Fatigue” and “Climate”.…”

Informal and hidden curricula in ethics teaching at Zagreb School of Medicine English program

“…The experiences of our students can be corroborated by other research on informed consent practices and patient autonomy in Croatia (Vucemilo et al 2013;Vucemilo and Borovecki 2014). For this reason greater importance should be dedicated to patient autonomy issues in medical education in Croatia (Murgic et al 2015).…”

Informed Consent: A Complex Process in Iran's Nursing Practice

“…Age, education level, cultural diversity and illness are all identified as potential characteristics that may make the subject less able to comprehend information given to them during the informed consent process [30]. Level of education, apart from age, also has been found to be a significant factor in the ability of a potential subject to comprehend and recall information provided during the informed consent process [31]. An understanding of cultural differences is also very important for providing quality of care.…”