Parent-Endorsed Sex Differences in Toddlers with and Without ASD: Utilizing the M-CHAT

Abstract

Sex differences in typical development can provide context for understanding ASD. Baron-Cohen (Trends Cogn Sci 6(6):248–254, 2002) suggested ASD could be considered an extreme expression of normal male, compared to female, phenotypic profiles. In this paper, sex-specific M-CHAT scores from N = 53,728 18-month-old toddlers, including n = 185 (32 females) with ASD, were examined. Results suggest a nuanced view of the “extreme male brain theory of autism”. At an item level, almost every male versus female disadvantage in the broader population was consistent with M-CHAT vulnerabilities in ASD. However, controlling for total M-CHAT failures, this male disadvantage was more equivocal and many classically ASD-associated features were found more common in non-ASD. Within ASD, females showed relative strengths in joint attention, but impairments in imitation.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1007/s10803-016-2945-8) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Clinical Features of Children With Autism Who Passed 18-Month Screening

“…Specifically, boys in both groups were more advanced than girls in gross motor skills, a finding that is consistent with findings in earlier work on children with ASD 35,36 as well as in typically developing children. 37,38 Furthermore, consistent with previous work, 21,39 boys had a higher activity level than girls.…”

Sex Differences in Autism Spectrum Disorder: a Review

“…This has been supported by a number of studies [95,96]. EMB theory also predicts that sex differences found in the general population would be absent or reduced in individuals with ASD, which has also been demonstrated recently with SQ and EQ traits in adults and toddlers with ASD [97,98]. …”

What About the Girls? Sex-Based Differences in Autistic Traits and Adaptive Skills

“…There is no clear theoretical reason why the female protective effect would be stronger as cognitive ability increases, and thus it seems likely that current diagnostic procedures fail to adequately identify females with higher intellectual abilities. There are indications that this disparity impacts even early screening procedures, as prior studies have found that parents’ first concerns differ by sex (Hiller et al 2016; Little et al 2016), and at least one recent study has found sex differences at the item-level on the Modified Checklist for Autism in Toddlers (M-CHAT), one of the most widely-used early ASD screening instruments (Øien et al 2017).…”