Results of replicate oxidation runs on high volatile A bituminous coal (PSOC 4) show in Figure 2 that reaction rate is reproducible for the same type of coal and particle size, usually to within the experimental precision, but never exceeding a deviation of 5 % for any given point. In all the figures, runs marked with a letter A were obtained with the newer apparatus; those labeled with a W R Ri Ro t = time,hr , "The Oxidation of Bituminous Coal, Part 1: "Development of a Mathematical Model," Chem. Eng. Sci., 31, 815 (1976a).