Upon reduction, singly bonded 1,2,4,15-C60 dimers with an oxazoline or imidazoline heterocycle dissociate into monoanionic 1,2,4-C60 intermediates, which surprisingly leads to the formation of 1,2,3,16-C60 rather than 1,2,4,15-C60 adducts of the original configuration by further benzylation, even though the analogue of dibenzylated C60 oxazoline with a 1,2,4,15-configuration is stable and has been obtained. These results are corroborated by computational calculations, which rationalize the reaction and clarify the structure of the 1,2,3,16-C60 adducts, providing new insights into the intrinsic reactivity of singly bonded C60 dimers.