Organizational uncertainty and stress among teachers in Hong Kong: work characteristics and organizational justice

Abstract

A growing literature now exists examining the relationship between organizational justice and employees' experience of stress. Despite the growth in this field of enquiry, there remain continued gaps in knowledge. In particular, the contribution of perceptions of justice to employees' stress within an organizational context of uncertainty and change, and in relation to the new and emerging concept of procedural-voice justice. The aim of the current study was to examine the main, interaction and additive effects of work characteristics and organizational justice perceptions to employees' experience of stress (as measured by their feelings of helplessness and perceived coping) during an acknowledged period of organizational uncertainty. Questionnaires were distributed among teachers in seven public primary schools in Hong Kong that were under threat of closure (n = 212). Work characteristics were measured using the demand-control-support model. Hierarchical regression analyses observed perceptions of job demands and procedural-voice justice to predict both teachers' feelings of helplessness and perceived coping ability. Furthermore, teacher's perceived coping was predicted by job control and a significant interaction between procedural-voice justice and distributive justice. The addition of organizational justice variables did account for unique variance, but only in relation to the measure of perceived coping. The study concludes that in addition to 'traditional' work characteristics, health promotion strategies should also address perceptions of organizational justice during times of organizational uncertainty; and, in particular, the value and importance of enhancing employee's perceived 'voice' in influencing and shaping justice-related decisions.

Exploring the impact of teacher emotions on their approaches to teaching: A structural equation modelling approach

“…Furthermore, a series of intensive educational reforms in Mainland China and Hong Kong has been implemented in which teachers are facing increasing academic accountability (Cheng, ; Tan & Chua, ). This, unfortunately, results in that teachers are suffering from a higher level of anxiety and pressure to enhance students' academic achievement and to interact with different stakeholders (Hassard, Teoh, & Cox, ). These highlight the urgency of investigating teacher emotions and its impacts on their teaching in the research sites.…”

Occupational stress and associated factors among college instructors in Eritrea: A cross-sectional study 2019

“…Similar findings were reported in a study conducted in Russia where instability and uncertainty of organizational changes were identified as causes of stress, innovation fatigue, and emotional burnout 42 . Likewise, a study on Hong Kong teachers revealed employees experience stress during an acknowledged period of organizational uncertainty 43 . The significance of teachers' participation on decision making, for enhancing their organizational roles as professional decision makers, has been emphasized as lack of participation, is expected to result in negative outcomes including stress 44 .…”

Research Review on Teacher Emotion in Asia Between 1988 and 2017: Research Topics, Research Types, and Research Methods

“…Second, teacher emotion plays a crucial role in teacher well-being (Fried et al, 2015). Teachers nowadays experience more negative emotions than positive ones (Thompson, 2014; Hassard et al, 2016) and teachers in Asia have been diagnosed and suffer from the same problem of negative emotions in recent years (Chen, 2019). Negative emotions and an inadequate capacity of emotion regulation continues to rank as one of the major reasons for teacher burnout and for teachers leaving their profession (Akin et al, 2013).…”