Order Effects and Employment Decisions: Experimental Evidence from a Nationwide Program

Abstract

In this paper, we show that order effects operate in the context of high-stakes, real-world decisions: employment choices. We experimentally evaluate a nationwide program in Ecuador that changed the order of teaching vacancies on a job application platform in order to reduce teacher sorting (that is, lower-income students are more likely to attend schools with less qualified teachers). In the treatment arm, the platform showed hard-to-staff schools (institutions typically located in more vulnerable areas that normally have greater difficulty attracting teachers) first, while in the control group teaching vacancies were displayed in alphabetical order. In both arms, hard-to-staff schools were labeled with an icon and identical information was given to teachers. We find that a teacher in the treatment arm was more likely to apply to hard-to-staff schools, to rank them as their highest priority, and to be assigned to a job vacancy in one of these schools. The effects were not driven by inattentive, altruistic, or less-qualified teachers. The program has thus helped to reduce the unequal distribution of qualified teachers across schools of different socioeconomic backgrounds.

Teacher transfers and the disruption of Teacher Staffing in the City of Sao Paulo

“…In light of the strong preference for establishments close to home, some school systems offer transportation and housing subsidies (Pugatch & Schroeder, 2014). More recently, govern-ments in Latin America have been experimenting with behavioral nudges to attract teachers to disadvantaged schools (Ajzenman et al, 2020;Ajzenman et al, 2021). The research shows that simple low-cost interventions are effective at encouraging teachers to apply to hard-to-staff schools, offering a promising alternative to financial incentives at a time when economic growth is low and education budgets are tight.…”

Digitalizing Public Services: Opportunities for Latin America and the Caribbean

“…This chapter presents a conceptual framework and reviews evidence on how technology can contribute to reduce dropout rates and improve learning. The framework focuses on teaching and learning interventions, although emerging evidence also suggests technology can be used to support school management, such as by improving teacher assignments to schools (Ajzenman et al 2021).…”

Education in the Amazon Region

“…The results show that the initiative increased the teachers' likelihood to apply for positions at schools with hard-to-fill openings, by classifying these openings as their own priority and agreeing to assignments in one of these schools. Therefore, it can be concluded that the program contributed to reduce the unequal distribution of qualified teachers in schools from different socioeconomic contexts (Ajzenman et al, 2021).…”