“…Table 3 shows the best and worst results of 20 independent runs for the different PSO approaches. Other published results found for the same problem using different optimization approaches including gradient based algorithms both unconstrained (Schimit & Miura, 1976), and constrained (Gellatly & Berke, 1971;Dobbs & Nelson, 1976;Rizzi, 1976;Haug & Arora, 1979;Haftka & Gurdal, 1992;Memari & Fuladgar, 1994), structural approximation algorithms (Schimit & Farshi, 1974), convex programming (Adeli & Kamal, 1991, Schmit & Fleury, 1980, non-linear goal programming (El-Sayed & Jang, 1994), and genetic algorithms (Ghasemi et al, 1997;Galante, 1992) are also shown in Tables 3 and 4. Table 4.…”