“…Several approaches have been reported to improve the V oc -deficit and band-tailing characteristics such as (i) precisely controlling the compositional ratio such as Cu/(Zn + Sn) and Zn/Sn or annealing conditions like temperature, time, initial stage pressure, and additives (i.e., Sn or SnS powder); ,− (ii) controlling the band alignment between buffer and absorber layers using alternative buffer materials such as (Cd x ,Zn 1– x )S, Zn(O x ,S 1– x ), In x S y , , (Zn x ,Sn 1– x )O, and (Cu x ,Al 1– x )O 2 or by partially alloying/doping Ge, Ag, or Cd in kesterite; ,,,− (iii) passivation in the junction region using wider band gap materials; , and (iv) introducing alkali elements such as Na, K, and Li, occupying V Cu defect sites. ,,, Among these approaches, the partial substitution of the Cu site by Ag in the kesterite system attracts the most attention and is promising because the radius of Ag + (1.14 Å) is substantially larger than that of Cu + (0.74 Å) . The crystal structures of CZTSSe and (Cu,Ag) 2 ZnSn(S x ,Se 1– x ) 4 (ACZTSSe) with expected defect clusters are shown in Figure S1, and the relevant discussion on defects and defect clusters is provided in the Results and Discussion part .…”