Older adults’ accounts of the relationships between retirement timing and health: a descriptive qualitative analysis in Chile

Abstract

Retirement timing can have important health implications. Little is known, however, about older adults’ views on this issue and whether they consider it better to retire later, earlier, on time or anytime. This knowledge gap about older adults’ views is particularly true outside North America and Europe. This qualitative study aims to examine older Chileans’ ideas about the relationship between retirement timing and health and to explore gender and class patterns in qualitative themes identified, knowledge which may strengthen quantitative population-based approaches. Framework analysis was conducted on qualitative accounts from a purposive, non-random sample of 40 older Chileans in six focus groups, stratified by gender and class as marked by lifetime occupation. Transcriptions were coded by two independent reviewers (inter-coder reliability = 81%) according to four deductive categories of retirement timing as well as inductive coding of emergent themes. The content and sequence of codes were visually represented in MAXQDA's document portraits and illustrated with descriptive quotes. Results indicate that participants’ views about when to retire in order to maximise health did not highlight retirement age or timing (later, earlier, on time, anytime). Instead, these older Chileans emphasised that the optimal retirement age depends on other conditions, such as employment quality, retirement income and gender. These views were patterned: lower occupational-class participants emphasised income and job hazards, higher-class males emphasised job satisfaction and higher-class females emphasised gendered patterns. Women and lower-class participants were relatively more favourable to earlier retirements than men and higher-class participants. Overall, qualitative analyses of lay perspectives from understudied country contexts complement and extend population-based models focused on timing or retirement age, suggest specific characteristics of retirement transitions that may moderate health consequences, and highlight class and gender differences in views of retirement timing. More research is needed using mixed-methods approaches and leveraging both purposive and random samples.

Intrinsic post-retirement work motivation in formal Chilean workers at retirement age: a qualitative study

“…The active ageing approach refers to older adults' participation in diverse areas, including economic, social or spiritual affairs, thus moving from a passive and dependent way of life in old age towards an engaged and dynamic lifestyle (Foster and Walker, 2013;Foster, 2018). Further, several studies found that staying economically active beyond legal retirement age can promote the physical, mental and social wellbeing of older adults (Rohwedder and Willis, 2010;Shura et al, 2022), an idea that is also reinforced in one of the latest works by Phillipson (2022). Therefore, an active ageing approach with its particular focus on older adults' economic activities can facilitate a better understanding of extended careers, challenges and opportunities encountered by an ageing population in this regard (Foster and Walker, 2013).…”

The Behavioral and Social Dimension of the Public Health System of European Countries: Descriptive, Canonical, and Factor Analysis

“…Descriptive analysis is also very often used in social sciences (18.56%). Scientists in this field are currently studying some aspects based on descriptive analysis, which include a descriptive analysis of complaints related to COVID-19 in California by Thomas M. D. et al [62]; a descriptive qualitative analysis of older adults' accounts in Chile by Shura R. et al [63]; and others such as Njegovanovic A. [64], Sarihasan I. et al [65], Pop R.-A.…”

Incentives behind and Experiences of Being Active in Working Life after Age 65 in Sweden

“…Known factors associated with being active in working life after the expected retirement age include a higher educational level, working within highly skilled occupations/professions, good health status, and being male [ 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 ]. Qualitative studies have revealed that perquisites and motivations for working life after the expected retirement age can include work satisfaction and good organizational support [ 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 ], financial incentives [ 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 ], social benefits [ 11 , 15 , 16 ], and/or having flexibility in work, e.g., time or tasks [ 14 , 15 , 16 , 18 ]. Earlier research has also shown that both managers [ 15 , 19 ] and workers [ 15 , 20 ] highlight good health as a key facilitator to an extended working life.…”