Ocean data portals: Performing a new infrastructure for ocean governance

Abstract

We are currently in what might be termed a “third phase” of ocean enclosures around the world. This phase has involved an unprecedented intensity of map-making that supports an emerging regime of ocean governance where resources are geocoded, multiple and disparate marine uses are weighed against each other, spatial tradeoffs are made, and exclusive rights to spaces and resources are established. The discourse and practice of marine spatial planning inform the contours of this emerging regime. This paper examines the infrastructure of marine spatial planning via two ocean data portals recently created to support marine spatial planning on the East Coast of the United States. Applying theories of ontological politics, critical cartography, and a critical conceptualization of “care,” we examine portal performances in order to link their organization and imaging practices with the ideological and ontological work these infrastructures do, particularly in relation to environmental and human community actors. We further examine how ocean ontologies may be made durable through portal use and repetition, but also how such performances can “slip,” thereby creating openings for enacting marine spatial planning differently. Our analysis reveals how portal infrastructures assemble, edit, and visualize data, and how it matters to the success of particular performances of marine spatial planning.

The post-political nature of marine spatial planning and modalities for its re-politicisation

“…Their capacity to produce such knowledge could be enhanced through citizen science (Nursey-Bray, Palmer, & Pecl, 2018;Kelly, Flemming, Pecl, Ritcher, & Bonn. 2019) and participatory mapping (Boucquey, St Martin, Fairbanks, Campbell, & Wise, 2019) projects that would enable them to provide alternative data to the technocratic, top-down forms of data collection. Attention to inclusive decision-making processes that confront issues of social justice is essential to achieving sustainable ocean management across sectors and jurisdictions (Bennett, 2018).…”

The Social Life of Robots: The Politics of Algorithms, Governance, and Sovereignty

“…While big environmental data sets present new opportunities for sense‐making in opaque and unwieldy environments, such as the ocean, the growing emphasis on algorithms and machine learning is transforming not only how we claim to know nature, but the very kinds of interventions, infrastructures, regimes of care, and resource governance modalities that become possible (Boucquey et al ; Gabrys ; Lehman ). Big data and algorithmic governance have also infiltrated a site of more commonplace human–environment relations, the farm.…”

The territories of governance : unpacking the ontologies and geophilosophies of fixed to flexible ocean management, and beyond

“…These might appear as abstract, even stuffy words, irrelevant to the practical work of ocean governance. Yet they allow us to interrogate the very basis of ocean governance and its tools and techniques [10].…”