“…11 shows good agreement between the simulation performed by the present code (Alya) and the numerical results of ( Schroeter et al, 2011 , Shang et al, 2015 , Shi et al, 2007 ). Differences in deposition results are due to the coarser airway surfaces in the replica producing higher deposition efficiencies than the numerical model, already observed frequently in literature, see Bahmanzadeh, Abouali, Faramarzi, and Ahmadi (2015) and Shi et al (2007) who provide an extended study which can be summarized as the “wall roughness region enhanced particle capturing effect” or other study ( Ghahramani, Abouali, Emdad, & Ahmadi, 2017 ) who compared deposition of different level of surface roughness replicas (see Fig. 11 Model A,B,C) from Kelly, Asgharian, Kimbell, and Wong (2004) with LES simulations.…”