Noise Induces Hopping between NF-κB Entrainment Modes

Abstract

SUMMARYOscillations and noise drive many processes in biology, but how both affect the activity of the transcription factor nuclear factor κB (NF-κB) is not understood. Here, we observe that when NF-κB oscillations are entrained by periodic tumor necrosis factor (TNF) inputs in experiments, NF-κB exhibits jumps between frequency modes, a phenomenon we call “cellular mode-hopping.” By comparing stochastic simulations of NF-κB oscillations to deterministic simulations conducted inside and outside the chaotic regime of parameter space, we show that noise facilitates mode-hopping in all regimes. However, when the deterministic system is driven by chaotic dynamics, hops between modes are erratic and short-lived, whereas in experiments, the system spends several periods in one entrainment mode before hopping and rarely visits more than two modes. The experimental behavior matches our simulations of noise-induced mode-hopping outside the chaotic regime. We suggest that mode-hopping is a mechanism by which different NF-κB-dependent genes under frequency control can be expressed at different times.

Oscillatory stimuli differentiate adapting circuit topologies

“…Dynamical stimuli have been used to explore biological pathways( 14 ) and to uncover interesting new biology( 15 – 18 ). Specifically, step-like and ramp-like inputs were applied to distinguish specific models( 8 , 19 – 23 ).…”

Universal signal generator for dynamic cell stimulation

“…Nevertheless, it is still unknown what dynamic chemotherapy would be optimal to administer. 36,37 Other studies highlight the role of dynamic biochemical signals in overcoming noise-induced information loss or gain 8,11,38 and the role of noise in spontaneous activation of gene networks. 39 It is unclear however what the circuit design principles are that allow cells to operate in the face of noise.…”

NF-κB, the Importance of Being Dynamic: Role and Insights in Cancer

“…Other popular non-tumour cell lines like RAW264.7, a murine macrophage-like line, have been used in some studies [ 53 , 54 , 55 ]. NIH-3T3 cells in which the RelA gene has been knock-out and its expression replaced by a transduced fluorescent RelA–DsRed fusion protein under control of the endogenous RelA promoter [ 9 , 56 , 57 ] have been used as well.…”

“…However, in long time lapses, photobleaching plus variations of the focus and of laser intensity might alter the proportionality between the light emitted from a cell compartment and the protein content. That is why internally normalized measures are often used in the field and include ratios of nuclear-to-cytoplasm intensities [ 8 , 14 , 50 , 57 ], nuclear-to-total intensities [ 18 ] or average intensities [ 10 , 54 ]. As we reasoned elsewhere [ 18 ], the nuclear-to-total ratio is proportional to the total nuclear amount as long as the protein amount per cell is constant throughout the time lapse.…”