“…Recent studies using step heating or step crushing, and Ne and Ar measurements on single samples have been performed on MORB and OIB and it seems clear that the mantle sources of most hotpots (e.g., Galapagos, Iceland, Hawaii) have 40 Ar/ 36 Ar ratios lower than 10,000, lower than the maximum MORB ratio of ~30,000 (Hiyagon et al, 1992;Honda et al, 1993;Moreira et al, 1995;Valbracht et al, 1997;Sarda et al, 2000;Trieloff et al, 2000;Trieloff et al, 2002;Honda and Woodhead, 2005;Hopp and Trieloff, 2005;Raquin and Moreira, 2009;Mukhopadhyay, 2012), but higher than the atmospheric ratio (299) which is the value that was proposed for the lower mantle by the Paris group in the 1980's. Another interesting approach used to determine the Ar isotopic composition of mantle reservoirs and document the isotopic heterogeneity of vesicles while avoiding atmospheric contamination was developed by Pete Burnard, now in Nancy (France) but who was then in Manchester (UK).…”