“…With the exception of a fairly recent study that explicitly compared effectiveness of different herbicides (Saleh and Oyinbo, 2017), none of the recent studies focussed on herbicide effectiveness or innovations in terms of formulations or applications. Herbicides were included in on-farm experiments to test integrated crop management (Toure et al, 2009;Senthilkumar et al, 2018) or improve fertiliser use efficiency (Kolo et al, 2021), as additional weed control intervention in water saving production approaches (de Vries et al, 2010;Krupnik et al, 2012b) or as benchmark to test the labour-saving potential of mechanical weeders (Rodenburg et al, 2015c). In a recent continent-wide survey, a number of herbicide products have been observed that were not reported before in the literature on African rice production systems (Table 5), but these do not comprise newly developed formulations.…”