New forms of distinction: How contemporary cultural elites understand ‘good’ taste

Abstract

Taste is a subject of longstanding academic interest. The question of how cultural interests and preferences are socially stratified is at the heart of the sociology of culture. This article adds to this literature by examining the tastes of a specific social fraction, those working in cultural and creative occupations ( N = 203). The analysis finds that, in keeping with existing quantitative research on changing cultural hierarchies, cultural workers are open and eclectic in their expressions of taste. They are reflexive, able to play with, and question, ideas of taste alongside conceptions of artistic or cultural legitimacy, connecting their understandings to broader questions of social division and distinction. At the same time, this ‘emerging’ form of cultural capital is a new dividing line, substantiated by modes of consumption, depth of appreciation, and willingness to articulate commitments to engagement with culture. These distinctive tastes of cultural workers matter because, as creators, commissioners and curators of what ends up on stage, page and screen, cultural workers’ tastes shape the cultural hierarchies of which they are a part. In the context of cultural and creative industries, we can expect that these new forms of distinction will serve to create group identities, providing yet another way that cultural elites are socially closed, in addition to well-known exclusions based on demographics such as race, class, gender, age or disability.

Liberal and anti-establishment: An exploration of the political ideologies of American tech workers

“…In addition, we uncover an ideological divide between tech workers and their leaders. The findings corroborate the notion that tech workers constitute a new and distinct class fraction and, from an even broader perspective, contribute to the sociology of professions (McAndrew et al, 2020; O’Brien & Ianni, 2023).…”

The Netflix Omnivore. The effect of streaming platforms on cultural diversity and inequalities

“…This is all the more true that we document a positive effect of streaming on cosmopolitanism, and that openness to foreign cultures is particularly well regarded in French elites (Wagner 2003). The cosmopolitan, omnivore attitude of streaming consumer parallels that of their curators (Bonini and Gandini 2019) and of the cultural workforce in general (O'Brien and Ianni 2023).…”

Distinctions in the making: A theoretical discussion of youth and cultural capital

“…This explains, in an American context, why there are signs of a turning inward of ‘highbrow’ culture, away from the ‘Veblensque’ display of conspicuous consumption towards a more modest orientation, as Sherman (2019) discusses amongst wealthy Manhattanites. A recent study of British cultural and creative workers (O’Brien & Ianni, 2022) also finds that a disdain for snobbery comes along with a social closure within the elites around their own shared cultural taste.…”