In this paper, we compare the metallurgical and low-temperature electronic properties of the pseudo-binary alloy systems Sc 1Ϫx U x Pd 3 and Y 1Ϫx U x Pd 3 to gain insight into the nature of the non-Fermi-liquid ͑NFL͒ behavior observed in these systems at low temperatures. Our results show that both the Sc 1Ϫx U x Pd 3 and Y 1Ϫx U x Pd 3 systems exhibit similar NFL behavior, in spite of significant differences in their metallurgical properties. This comparison provides strong evidence that the NFL behavior is an intrinsic property, and not an extrinsic property driven by metallurgical disorder. Scanning electron microscopy and x-ray-diffraction measurements revealed that the U in the Y 1Ϫx U x Pd 3 system is inhomogeneously distributed on the micron length scale, while the U in the Sc 1Ϫx U x Pd 3 system is nearly homogeneously distributed. However, low-temperature measurements of the electronic specific heat coefficient ␥ϭC p /T, magnetic susceptibility , and electrical resistivity show that the compounds Sc 0.7 U 0.3 Pd 3 and Y 0.8 U 0.2 Pd 3 exhibit the following NFL behavior with nearly the same Kondo temperature (T K ): C p