Neurosurgery in Contemporary Medical Dramas: How Grey's Anatomy & Co. May Affect Perception of Neurosurgery in the Media

Abstract

Background Neurosurgery is a common topic in contemporary medical dramas. This study aimed to examine depictions of several neurosurgical diseases and techniques as well as the perception of the personality of neurosurgeons in the media, focusing on their impact on the physician-patient relationship. Methods TV series and movies with a main focus on neurosurgeons and/or neurosurgical diseases were identified by consulting the International Movie Database (IMDb). Results After investigation of many TV series and movies, we identified five main topics: vascular neurosurgery, neuro-oncology, neurointensive care, neurosurgical techniques, and neurosurgeon's personality. The portrayal of neurosurgery in medical drama is characterized to a large extent by sensationalism, a lot of misinformation, and an unfavorable portrayal of neurosurgeons, although it is assumed that expert advice was sought in advance of every production. Conclusions Considering the popularity of medical dramas and movies dealing with medical topics, we must consider the general public's picture of neurosurgery to be widely influenced by the media.

Societal Preferences for Gender of Surgeons: A Cross‐Sectional Study in the General Population of Pakistan

“…The results like ours have been reported by a study conducted in Lebanon, where despite half the population reporting no gender preferences for surgeons overall, respondents were more likely to prefer male cardiac, orthopedic, and neurosurgeons over females [25]. Given the influence of mass media, it is likely that the historic predominance of surgeons across news media, medical dramas, and television shows reinforces gender biases in these specialties [26][27][28]. It is heartening, however, that social media movements such as #ILookLikeASurgeon and #YouCantBeWhatYouCantSee have made global strides in negating gender-based stereotypes by increasing the visibility of female surgeons around the world [29].…”

A Scoping Review of Professionalism in Neurosurgery

“…Publications that addressed professional identity were sometimes philosophical and sometimes practical. 10,15-65 Several articles addressed the concept of excellence in neurosurgery, 31-33,35,36 while others addressed the personality of a neurosurgeon. 20,61,62 Twelve of the indexed publications were presidential speeches from past presidents of the Congress of Neurological Surgeons (CNS), American Association of Neurological Surgeons (AANS), and several international neurosurgery societies.…”

The Politics of Fictional Medicine: Entertainment, Propaganda, and Education in Chinese Medical Dramas in the Xi Era

“…The article explores how different strands of ideological constructs and value systems are incorporated in a sample of contemporary Chinese TV series belonging to the medical drama genre. Current literature suggests that televised procedures and prognoses affect the viewers' health knowledge and behaviors (Kim and Kim 2019, Pilz et al 2020, Bitter et al 2021. In addition, through dramatization of key relationships in societies (i.e., Self/body, patient/doctor, physician/healthcare system), medical TV series influence the audiences' perceptions of hospitals, as well as the patients' trust in doctors (Chen 2019, Kohler et al 2019, Tian and Yoo 2020.…”