Nation-Delegation-Constitution: Reconsidering role of religion in Polish identity development

Abstract

Democratic politics creates a specific ‘chain of representation’. According to Article 104 of the Polish Constitution, the MPs are the representatives of the entire Nation. The understanding of the “entire Nation” allows to determine whether national identity is open and inclusive, or closed and exclusive. One can distinguish two ideal types of a nation: heterogeneous and homogeneous. The first type is connected to the universalist understanding of “constitutional essentials”, the second to the particularistic one. In the paper, we pointed out the elements of heterogeneity in the text of Polish constitutions as well as the elements of homogeneity in the constitutional practice. Religion becomes an important factor influencing the interpretation and application of the constitution. The heterogeneous concept of the nation and the universalist “constitutional essentials” can be narrowed down in the political practice. The particularistic elements of the constitution and the homogenizing tendencies present in the application of the constitution might lead to polarization. In such a case, there would be a radical reinterpretation of the entire chain of delegation.

Law and Diversity: European and Latin American Experiences from a Legal Historical Perspective - Vol. 1: Fundamental Questions

“…At the same time, it is worth noting that the Polish interwar constitutions were created in completely different factual circumstances from the post-war ones. The constitutions of 1921 and 1935 were established for a multi-ethnic, 6 multilingual, multidenominational and multicultural state, Carrying out the census in those times did not raise such controversy as, for example, under Prussian rule [Belzyt (2013) and its polemics], although, of course, the process was The Constitutional Embedding of Differences, 1921Differences, -1997 The Polish Example which inherited three key legal orders after the partition and did not fully unify them until the outbreak of the Second World War. The Constitutions of 1952 and 1997 were created in different conditions: as the state shifted geographically (in 1945), the result was the creation of a homogenous state in many respects.…”

Examining the Impact of a Third Culture Kid Upbringing: Wellbeing, Attachment and Ethnic Identity Strength in Adult Third Culture Kids

“…This finding could be of use to parents, international school staff, and even counsellors of TCKs, as it suggests that TCKs who are religious should be enabled, where possible, to practise their religion whilst in the host country, in order to help improve their ethnic identity development. A relationship between religion and identity development has been highlighted by Bień et al (2019), while noting religion’s association with low mental health help-seeking (Lloyd et al, 2021) as ‘religion’ is a broad term. Future research is needed to further evaluate religion and ethnic identity strength.…”