Národní identita členského štátu jako dôvod poskytnutia odlišnej miery ochrany základných práv v porovnaní s Chartou základných práv EÚ

Miháliková, Valéria

doi:10.14712/23366478.2018.32

Cited by 2 publications

(2 citation statements)

References 8 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Order By: Relevance

“…Attention to the particular case-law of the Court of Justice of the European Union was already paid elsewhere, 46 we will, however, propose several conclusions in that regard.…”

Section: National Identity Within the Case-law Of The Cjeumentioning

confidence: 97%

“…Constitutional identity is therefore according to him constructed vis-à-vis national identity, it is, however, consistent with it and has to be continuously in a dynamic tension with national as well as other identities. 10 The above-mentioned conceptual ambiguities regarding the concept of national identity enshrined in the Article 4(2) TEU are closely linked with its application in practice. National identity used interchangeably as a constitutional identity -as an unamendable core of a Member State's constitution -would result in applying this concept as an exception to the absolute primacy of the EU law over national law of EU Member States.…”

Section: National Identity and Constitutional Identity And Practical mentioning

confidence: 99%

See 1 more Smart Citation

National and Constitutional Identity in the Case-Law of Constitutional Courts of the Visegrad Group

Miháliková¹

2020

STUDIA IURIDICA Cassoviensia

Self Cite

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

After the inclusion of the EUʹs obligation to respect national identities of its Member States into the primary law of the European Union, the notion of national identity has become an object of the interest of constitutional courts of EU Member States. They have, at the same time, started to use the notion of constitutional identity with regard to the European integration in their case-law. The object of this article is to analyse the case-law of the constitutional courts of the Visegrad group regarding the notions of national identity and constitutional identity and to analyse the means of using these concepts in their case-law, in particular with regard to the use of the concept of national identity within the meaning of the Article 4 (2) of the Treaty on European Union in the case-law of the Court of Justice of the European Union. ABSTRAKT Po tom, čo bola v primárnom práve Európskej únie ustanovená povinnosť Únie rešpektovať národné identity jej členských štátov, sa stal pojem národná identita čoraz častejším objektom pozornosti ústavných súdov členských štátov Únie. Súčasne sa v judikatúre týchto súdov začal v súvislosti s európskou integráciou používať pojem ústavná identita, mnohokrát spájaný práve s národnou identitou. Cieľom tohto článku je priblížiť judikatúru ústavných súdov štátov Vyšehradskej skupiny zaoberajúcu sa pojmami národná identita a ústavná identita a zhodnotiť spôsob, akým sú tieto koncepty v ich judikatúre využívané, a to predovšetkým s ohľadom na využitie konceptu národnej identity v zmysle článku 4 ods. 2 Zmluvy o Európskej únii v judikatúre Súdneho dvora Európskej únie. 8 Article 6(3) TEU in the wording of the Amsterdam Treaty stated: "The Union shall respect the national identities of its Member States." 9

show abstract

“…Attention to the particular case-law of the Court of Justice of the European Union was already paid elsewhere, 46 we will, however, propose several conclusions in that regard.…”

Section: National Identity Within the Case-law Of The Cjeumentioning

confidence: 97%

Section: National Identity and Constitutional Identity And Practical mentioning

confidence: 99%

National and Constitutional Identity in the Case-Law of Constitutional Courts of the Visegrad Group

Miháliková¹

2020

STUDIA IURIDICA Cassoviensia

Self Cite

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

Conference Report: International Scientific Conference on ‘Theoretical and Practical Aspects of Constitutional Identity’

Mádl

2023

CEJoCL

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

One of the most significant questions in Europe is constitutional identity. The progression of globalisation and the federalisation of the European Union (EU), hindered sovereignty of the member states. In this climate, the notion of constitutional identity, which is a component of national identity enshrined in constitutions, has become one of the key tools for regaining autonomy. Many conflicting opinions have emerged in the scholarly world regarding the application of constitutional identity. One view is that it is just a vague instrument that aims to obstruct European integration, while another group of experts states that it is the last resort to stop the enforcement of an ideologically filled common identity generated by judicial organs, which is often contrary to national identities. To discuss this topic, a research group titled ‘Constitutional Identity and Relations Between the EU Law and the Domestic Law of the Member States’ was established. The group of renowned experts from France, Germany, the Czech Republic, Croatia, Hungary, Poland, Romania, Italy, and the Slovak Republic led by Professor András Zs. Varga conducted structured scientific research using a common questionnaire. The first outcome of their work was the International Scientific Conference on the ‘Theoretical and Practical Aspects of Constitutional Identity’ presented at the Faculty of Law and Political Sciences of the Pázmány Péter Catholic University in Budapest. The event served as an extraordinary opportunity to observe the meaning of constitutional identity in member countries, how it is protected, and the similarities and differences between member states. In this short report, I summarised the fundamental points of each presentation to provide key themes and messages.

show abstract

Národní identita členského štátu jako dôvod poskytnutia odlišnej miery ochrany základných práv v porovnaní s Chartou základných práv EÚ

Cited by 2 publications

References 8 publications

National and Constitutional Identity in the Case-Law of Constitutional Courts of the Visegrad Group

National and Constitutional Identity in the Case-Law of Constitutional Courts of the Visegrad Group

Conference Report: International Scientific Conference on ‘Theoretical and Practical Aspects of Constitutional Identity’

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About