“…Therefore, TBD indeed has the advantages of providing a higher probability of detection at the same level of probability of false alarms, while circumventing the troublesome data association problem. TBD has a large family, and many algorithms can fall into this category, such as the Hough transform (HT) [15][16][17][18], maximum likelihood approach (MLA) [19,20], sequential hypothesis testing [21,22], maximum likelihood-probabilistic data association (ML-PDA) [3,4], [23,24], particle filter track-beforedetect (PF-TBD) [25][26][27][28][29], 3D matched filtering [30,31], 4D-TBD [32], dynamic programming (DP) [33][34][35], etc. During the past several decades, many extensive studies of TBD have been published in the available literature.…”