Moving In and Moving Up? Labor Conditions and China's Changing Development Model

Abstract

Summary For the last decade, a large contingent of manufacturing firms in developmental zones on China's coast has moved to inland provinces. What are the implications of this move inland for Chinese workers? Research on labor conditions in the current period of economic globalization and mobile capital debates the existence of a “race to the bottom” in labor standards through the pressures of international capital mobility. These theories predict that as inland China develops and attracts a larger amount of foreign and domestic capital, inland governments will compete by offering cheap labor and lower or unenforced standards. Our argument in this paper is contrarian in that we propose the possibility of a positive relationship between the movement inland and labor conditions. We argue that the movement of manufacturing to inland China is not primarily about cheaper workers, but instead signals the beginning of a fundamental shift in the development model through the employment of a localized workforce. Having more workers from within the province, local governments in inland provinces will be more inclined to develop inclusive social policies and improve labor conditions. Local governments in coastal provinces that inherit fundamentally different demographic structures are less likely to pursue this governance style. We use audit data from Apple corporation suppliers (2007–2013), supplementary survey data, and in‐depth interviews to discuss the relationship between localized production and better labor conditions. Copyright © 2017 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Crossvergence of socially (ir)responsible employment practices in supplier firms

“…size, skill level and nationality) Competitors -Characteristics of local competition (e.g. intensity, degree of cooperation, CSR standards) Industry reputation -The labor-related CSR reputation of the local industry Technology -The standard type of technology and degree of automatization used in the local industry Production process -The standard production process used in the local industry Ali and Jadoon (2012), Azmeh (2014); Bartley (2010), Budhwar and Sparrow (2002); Donaghey et al (2014), Huq et al (2014); Jiang et al (2012, Punia and Sharma (2015), Yang and Gallagher (2017) scientists and practitioners warn that compliance with international labor standards is hampered by lead firms' demands for decreases in price and lead time (Oka, 2010;Lund-Thomsen et al, 2012). A supervisor in China vividly summarizes the resulting conflict for suppliers:…”

Investigation of Collapsed Building Incidents on Soft Marine Deposit: Both from Social and Technical Perspectives

“…Accelerating economic development in rural areas of China has raised the demands for residential housing for the economic migration of workers to the developing suburbs of cities [38,39]. These residential demands increase the low-rental market of apartments; however, the market cannot provide enough low-rental apartments [40].…”

“…It has also created job opportunities for many migrant laborers [38,39]. However, there are a number of challenges in the process of land policy reform [41,42].…”

The Quality of Governance in China and Beyond: Introduction to Special Issue

“…Yujeong Yang and Mary Gallagher (Yang and Gallagher, ) discuss labour conditions and China's changing development model. In the last decade, as well noted, a large contingent of manufacturing firms in developmental zones on China's coast has moved to inland provinces.…”