Mothers say “baby” and their newborns do not choose to listen: a behavioral preference study to compare with ERP results

Abstract

Previously published results from neonatal brain evoked response potential (ERP) experiments revealed different brain responses to the single word “baby” depending on whether it was recorded by the mother or an unfamiliar female. These results are consistent with behavioral preference studies in which infants altered pacifier sucking to contingently activate recordings of the maternal vs. an unfamiliar female voice, but the speech samples were much longer and information-rich than in the ERP studies. Both types of neonatal voice recognition studies imply postnatal retention of prenatal learning. The preference studies require infant motor and motivation systems to mount a response in addition to voice recognition. The current contingent sucking preference study was designed to test neonatal motivation to alter behavior when the reward is the single word “baby” recorded by the mother or an unfamiliar speaker. Results showed an absent or weak contingent sucking response to the brief maternal voice sample, and they demonstrate the complementary value of electrophysiological and behavioral studies for very early development. Neonates can apparently recognize the maternal voice in brief recorded sample (previous ERP results) but they are not sufficiently motivated by it to alter sucking behavior.

The transition to parenthood in obstetrics: enhancing prenatal care for 2-generation impact

“…20−24 Of note, 3-day-old infants have shown that they can identify their mother's voice vs another woman's voice, 2 sucking more vigorously on a nonnutritive nipple to elicit hearing it. 25 Newborn recognition of maternal voices vs a stranger's voice has been shown in electrophysiological signals as well. 26 Newborns demonstrate memory from the in utero period for a spoken passage or melody even if produced by an unfamiliar speaker.…”

Defining Attachment and Bonding: Overlaps, Differences and Implications for Music Therapy Clinical Practice and Research in the Neonatal Intensive Care Unit (NICU)

“…While individual differences exist in terms of timing, duration, and form, the maternal–fetal relationship usually intensifies over time, although many mothers experience a significant shift when they notice the first fetal movements in the transition from the 2nd to the 3rd trimester [ 6 , 7 ]. This is also the time when the baby progressively reacts to external stimuli such as the mother’s voice and touch [ 8 , 9 ] and thus it is no surprise that parents increasingly start interacting with their baby during this time. The paternal–fetal relationship is not yet as well investigated, but it has been shown that also men go through physiological and psychological changes in their journey towards fatherhood, which influence the quality of their interactions with the newborn after birth [ 10 ].…”

Editorial: Bridging the gap before and after birth: methods and technologies to explore the functional neural development in humans

“…In line with prior findings on the development of the adult fronto-parietal network for adaptive online task control, which involves both segregation and integration, the authors showed that this network, which provides a neurophysiological basis for the action-perception coupling, evolved with age from a more random to an adult small-world organization, more efficient for both local and global information processing. Another study regarding the development of the infant motor and motivation systems was conducted by Moon et al ( 2015 ), who designed a contingent sucking preference study to test neonatal motivation to the mother or an unfamiliar female. Although difficult to demonstrate, electrophysiological studies showed that newborns use prenatal experiences and the motivational system to produce responses to familiar sounds.…”