Modeling Reverse Logistics Barriers in Manufacturing Industry of Pakistan: An ISM and MICMAC Approach

Abstract

Due to industrialization, increasing solid waste is affecting environmental integrity globally. Reverse logistics (RL) has become a significant tool to deal with environmental degradation issues, and it is being implemented in developed countries. However, RL is at the infancy stage in developing countries especially in Pakistan due to different obstacles. This study aims to identify and analyzes the interrelationship between barriers affecting RL implementation in Pakistani manufacturing industry using an integrated methodology of Interpretive Structural Modeling (ISM) and MICMAC approach. Results of ISM and MICMAC identified organizational, financial, and technological barriers as dependent barriers. However, lack of government policy incentives, lack of responsiveness about RL, lack of enforceable laws on product return, changing in regulations due to political changes, lack of environmental law awareness and lack of corporate social responsibility emerged out as top-ranked barriers driving other barriers that need to be addressed. An inter-relationship based structural model will be helpful for supply chain and RL professional in understanding major obstacles to RL implementation and develop a strategy to promote RL in the manufacturing industry.

Closing the loop: Establishing reverse logistics for a circular economy, a systematic review

“…Financial and economic barriers emerged as one of the most prevalent barriers. Processes related to RL, for instance, collection and transportation, are expensive (Prakash and Barua, 2016;Waqas et al, 2020). Low profitability on account of high initial investments and operating costs and limited return on investments detriment RL adoption (Prakash and Barua, 2016).…”

Mapping Interactions among Green Innovations Barriers in Manufacturing Industry Using Hybrid Methodology: Insights from a Developing Country

“…However, as Table 7 indicates, it does not feature among the top five barriers of other countries. Recent study of Waqas et al [128] mentioned that lack of enforceable laws on product return is a major barrier in reverse logistics in Pakistan manufacturing sector. Earlier studies identified the lack of financial support [57], implementation of environmental policies [58], additional cost due to green innovation as top ranked barriers to green innovation practices.…”

Sustainable supply chain management and green technologies: a bibliometric review of literature

“…Sustainable supply chain practices refer to those actions and activities that deal with the environmental, financial, and social aspects of manufacturing firms (Waqas et al 2020 ). The optimization of SSCM activities decreased the demand for reverse logistics, predominately minimizing waste generation, promoting sustainable transportation, and recycling and reusing the waste material that is the foundation for the circular economy (Lee et al 2014 ; Ranjbari et al 2021 ).…”