Misuse through short-term rentals on the Berlin housing market

Abstract

Purpose Short-term rentals are mainly of small flats, which are offered to tourists. Currently, the providers of short-term rentals, in particular Airbnb (ABB), are being criticized in several German cities, on the grounds that shares of residential flats are being removed from the housing market, due to illegitimate misuse as tourist accommodation. Thus, the conventional urban housing markets are contending with a decline in housing supply and increasing rents. This paper aims to support these findings empirically. Design/methodology/approach The paper opted first for a spatial analysis with ArcGIS for ABB in Berlin. Second, different online data requests of periods of up to two months were used to analyze the extent of misuse with regard to the Zweckentfremdungsverbot (misuse prohibition law). Third, analysis of variance was used to analyze rental growth on the ABB markets. The data were collected in different approaches from the website of airbnb.com. Findings The paper provides evidence that 5,555 residential flats are presently being misused by ABB (0.30 per cent of the total housing stock in Berlin) and that many providers of entire flats have more than one offer simultaneously. Moreover, the paper provides the first entire-market overview of ABB in Berlin. It is evident that the ABB market is mainly located centrally and that only a few neighborhoods have large ABB markets. Rental growth is higher in the ABB markets which have a significant share of misused flats, than in the ABB markets which have insignificant shares of misused flats. Originality/value To the authors’ best knowledge, the paper provides the first empirical approach regarding misuse through short-term rentals on a housing market with an innovative design and first-hand data.

Displacement by disruption: short-term rentals and the political economy of “belonging anywhere” in Toronto

“…While housing anxieties are particularly acute in Toronto, with a rental vacancy rate of 1.2% in 2018 (Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation [CMHC], 2017), the exponential expansion of short-term rental listings has prompted critical work across the world by a range of actors, including: academics (Barron, Kung, & Proserpio, 2018;Davidson & Infranca, 2016;Ferreri & Sanyal, 2018;Finck & Ranchordás, 2016;Gant, 2016;Germann Molz, 2018;Gurran & Phibbs, 2017;Gutierrez, García-Palomares, Romanillos, & Salas-Olmedo, 2017;Holman, Mossa, & Pani, 2018;Keren & Merante, 2017;Lambea Llop, 2017;Lee, 2016;Mermet, 2017;Schäfer & Braun, 2016;Wachsmuth et al, 2017;Wachsmuth & Weisler, 2018), activists (Cox and SLee, 2016;Slee, 2015;Wieditz, 2017), think tanks (Crommelin, Troy, Martin, & Parkinson, 2018;Jamasi & Hennessy, 2016) and city staff (City of Toronto, 2017;San Francisco Planning Department, 2015). Amidst a heated political climate coloured by a range of perspectives, a critical geographical approach has much to offer in interpreting the impacts of short-term rentals.…”

Airbnb and taxation: Developing a seasonal tax system

“…Airbnb is a privately owned rental website that provides a peer-to-peer platform for individuals to rent rooms, flats, apartments, villas, and other temporary accommodations at a wide range of prices. However, there is criticism of the commercial use of Airbnb by property owners and landlords, which may affect local housing markets unfavorably through increasing rental fees (Schäfer and Braun, 2016;Wachsmuth and Weiser, 2018). Therefore, commercial practices (i.e., permanently rented entire units) should be considered in addition to home sharing to fully understand the platform's role in the accommodation sector (Kadi et al, 2019).…”

The Value of Proximity to a Vacation Home Rental in a Resort Community

“…In examining the "misuse" of VHRs in Berlin (Germany), Schafer and Braun (2016) study the cost that such imposes upon the traditional hotel industry through lost overnight stays, and upon permanent residents through a loss in conventional housing and higher rents. They identify misuse as the owners of apartments turning them into permanent VHRs.…”