Mindsets of conspiracy: A typology of affinities towards conspiracy myths in digital environments

Abstract

In times of crisis, the spread of conspiracy myths increases since people seek answers to complex questions. Besides societal aspects, social media platforms, especially messenger services, have been identified as a positive driver for spreading conspiracy myths. Much research focused on whether right-wing populist attitudes correlate with belief in conspiracy myths resulting in inconsistent findings. We show that different anti-system attitudes and corresponding digital media usage can promote the affinity towards conspiracy myths apart from right-wing attitudes. With this paper, we first want to sharpen the terminology on ‘conspiracy myths’ and develop a scale to measure affinity towards conspiracy myths in different dimensions. We second use this scale to investigate different mindsets of conspiracy in the Swiss population. Third, we want to find out how the dimensions correlate with messenger usage. Based on data from a representative population survey in Switzerland from November to December 2020, we investigated different affinities towards conspiracy myths, represented by far-left, far-right, populist, anti-elitism, general anti-system attitudes and science skepticism. We then used the six dimensions in a cluster analysis and identified five typological mindsets. About 30% of the population accordingly have higher affinities towards conspiracy myths than the rest. Our study also highlights the potential role of messenger services in spreading conspiracy myths. To a certain extent, Facebook Messenger and Telegram usage show a robust correlation with the different dimensions of the affinity towards conspiracy myths. In contrast, WhatsApp usage does not show a robust correlation.

Conspiracy as a surrogate for religion? Religiosity, spirituality, and affinity towards conspiracy myths in times of crisis

“…Die Skala zur Messung der Affinität gegenüber Verschwörungsmythen (Schwaiger et al. 2022 ) besteht aus zwölf Items, die jeweils auf einer fünfstufigen Likert-Skala beantwortet wurden (siehe Anhang). Die Skala misst Affinität gegenüber Verschwörungsmythen in unterschiedlichen Dimensionen mit jeweils zwei Items, darunter Anti-Elitismus (z.…”

Teorías de la conspiración y crisis globales: retos para la teoría sociológica

“…El locus natural de las TdC son los entornos online donde falsedades, medias verdades, bulos y fake news prosperan sin control (Molina et al, 2021). Estos autores ponen el foco en cómo las narrativas conspirativas se transmiten en Internet y en el papel de los medios digitales en su difusión (Schwaiger et al, 2022;Zeng et al, 2022). Siguiendo esta idea, la creencia en que las TdC han prevalecido a lo largo de la historia de la humanidad topan con la visibilidad, ubicuidad y popularidad de la que gozan ahora.…”

“…Siguiendo esta idea, la creencia en que las TdC han prevalecido a lo largo de la historia de la humanidad topan con la visibilidad, ubicuidad y popularidad de la que gozan ahora. El terreno online es un espacio abonado para su crecimiento descontrolado ya que existen las condiciones informativas para que broten "afinidades hacia los mitos conspirativos" (Schwaiger et al, 2022(Schwaiger et al, , p. 1022. Los patrones de consumo relacionados con los contenidos conspirativos en plataformas de medios sociales muestran la formación de nichos y el efecto de cámaras de eco como elementos fundamentales de la comunicación en las TdC (Cinelli et al, 2022).…”

Conspiracy theories in digital environments: Moving the research field forward

“… Schwaiger and colleagues’ (2022) article ‘Mindsets of Conspiracy: A Typology of Affinities towards Conspiracy Myths in Digital Environments’ surveys Swiss populations’ conspiracy mindsets. Their results from a representative population survey show a robust correlation between individuals’ affinity towards conspiracy theories and the usage of Facebook Messenger and Telegram.…”

“…Qualitative findings from the study demonstrate that the political discourse concerning the Great Replacement theory is used instrumentally by centre and far-right actors. Also focusing on far-right movements, Schulze and colleagues’ (2022) paper ‘Far-right Conspiracy Groups on Fringe Platforms’ studies conspiracy theories in the context of radicalisation. The authors conceptualise the prevalence of the conspiracy narrative as an indicator of radicalisation dynamics and study its temporal change among far-right movements in Germany.…”