It has been established that the large conductance Ca2+-activated K+ channel contains two types of high-affinity Ca2+ binding sites, termed the Ca2+ bowl and the RCK1 site. The affinities of these sites, and how they change as the channel opens, is still a subject of some debate. Previous estimates of these affinities have relied on fitting a series of conductance–voltage relations determined over a series of Ca2+ concentrations with models of channel gating that include both voltage sensing and Ca2+ binding. This approach requires that some model of voltage sensing be chosen, and differences in the choice of voltage-sensing model may underlie the different estimates that have been produced. Here, to better determine these affinities we have measured Ca2+ dose–response curves of channel activity at constant voltage for the wild-type mSlo channel (minus its low-affinity Ca2+ binding site) and for channels that have had one or the other Ca2+ binding site disabled via mutation. To accurately determine these dose–response curves we have used a series of 22 Ca2+ concentrations, and we have used unitary current recordings, coupled with changes in channel expression level, to measure open probability over five orders of magnitude. Our results indicate that at −80 mV the Ca2+ bowl has higher affinity for Ca2+ than does the RCK1 site in both the opened and closed conformations of the channel, and that the binding of Ca2+ to the RCK1 site is voltage dependent, whereas at the Ca2+ bowl it is not.