Metaphysik absoluter Relationalität

Iber, Christian

doi:10.1515/9783110872866

Cited by 36 publications

(3 citation statements)

References 0 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Order By: Relevance

“…On my reading, Hegel develops a structural metaphysics of freedom in his Science of Logic (see Baumann 2012). In making this claim, I follow Horstmann (1984Horstmann ( , 2006, Iber (1990Iber ( , 2000 and others in reading Hegel's Logic as a pre-Kantian and structural metaphysics. As Iber puts it, 'reality, be it spiritual or natural reality, is essentially structured by relations of form (Formverhältnisse), which are in turn graspable according to the formalities of our thought structures ' (2000: 15).…”

mentioning

confidence: 92%

Hegel on Market Laws and External Teleology

Baumann

2022

Hegel Bulletin

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

By highlighting the logico-metaphysical undergirding of Hegel's discussion of the market, this article brings to light certain proto-Marxist or proto-socialist tendencies in Hegel as well as key disagreements with Adam Smith, which have been missed by recent studies like Herzog's Inventing the Market (2013). For Smith, market laws function like an impartial arbiter that rewards honest effort; his main worry is that individuals may fail to display virtues like honesty, probity and frugality, thereby hindering the smooth functioning of the market mechanism. For Hegel, by contrast, the market is a de-personalized player in its own right that imposes its arbitrary rule, a rule that does not reflect in any way the virtues and efforts of market participants. This assessment is easily overlooked, unless one realizes that Hegel believes the market to be functioning according to the structures that he discusses in the ‘Objectivity’ section in his Science of Logic. As a consequence of this assessment Hegel attributes a different role to the state than Smith does: Rather than aiding and shaping individuals, by means of institutions, education and health care, the state needs to address the structural functioning of market laws and, to some extent, inhibit its free-flowing functioning. Individuals need to re-appropriate their own social relations by organizing them along the lines of the logical organism or internal teleology. After outlining Hegel's interpretation and assessment of the market structures with the help of the Logic, I will discuss Hegel's demand for an organic state, that sublates and oversees the market, thereby safeguarding the important personal freedoms enjoyed by market participants.

show abstract

mentioning

confidence: 92%

Hegel on Market Laws and External Teleology

Baumann

2022

Hegel Bulletin

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…9Iber defends the thesis of ‘the metaphysics of absolute relationality’ in the logic of essence through a detailed exposition of the beginning of the logic of essence (Iber 1990). …”

mentioning

confidence: 99%

Hegel’s Schein as Ideology of Equality and Freedom in Capitalism

Abazari¹

2017

Hegel Bulletin

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

In this paper, I demonstrate that the category of Schein (which I translate as ‘semblance’) in Hegel’s Science of Logic expresses the structure of ideology in general, and specifically the ideology of equality and freedom in capitalism. To this aim, I motivate Marx’s mature critique of political economy in Capital and the Grundrisse. I argue that while the semblance of equality is false and misleading, it is constitutive of the essence of capitalism. This implies that domination in capitalism does not exclude equality, but requires it. In particular, I argue that the structure of domination generates equality as its own necessary moment. The paper shows, on the one hand, how a close study of Hegel’s Logic is helpful for understanding the structure of capitalism, and on the other hand, how reading Hegel’s Logic through Marx can help in unveiling its social import.

show abstract

“…Segundo a sugestão de 229 Como vimos, a teoria da negatividade em Hegel quer evitar como resultado o zero ou o nada, respondendo assim ao perigo do niilismo que assombra as várias modalidades de negativismo que surgem na modernidade. Ele faz isso concebendo uma relacionalidade absoluta, como enfatizam Theunissen (1980, p. 47) e o estudo mais pormenorizado de Iber (1990) a respeito dessa estrutura. Hegel descobre na Ciência da lógica, diz Theunissen (1980, p. 46-47), "estruturas que colocam o todo da efetividade, não apenas as relações interpessoais, sob a exigência de uma relacionalidade absoluta [absoluter Relationalität]".…”

Section: (C) Negaçãounclassified

A lógica da teoria crítica em Adorno: um estudo sobre a >i<Dialética negativa>/i<

Santos

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

concessão da bolsa de doutorado no país, processo nº 2017/03781-4, e da bolsa de estágio de pesquisa no exterior, processo nº 2019/15103-6, propiciando assim o suporte financeiro necessário para a realização da pesquisa e escrita da tese. À/ao parecerista da FAPESP pelas proveitosas avaliações dos relatórios.Ao meu orientador, Luiz Repa, pelo acompanhamento diligente e confiança depositada no trabalho. Seu entusiasmo com o tema da pesquisa, o constante incentivo e suas leituras generosas tornaram essa trajetória muito menos desgastante.

show abstract

Metaphysik absoluter Relationalität

Cited by 36 publications

References 0 publications

Hegel on Market Laws and External Teleology

Hegel on Market Laws and External Teleology

Hegel’s Schein as Ideology of Equality and Freedom in Capitalism

A lógica da teoria crítica em Adorno: um estudo sobre a >i<Dialética negativa>/i<

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About