The development of electrocatalysts to meet the requirements of renewable energy applications has seen much attention placed on transition-metal dichalcogenide (TMD) materials owing to their promising properties. In particular, the strategy of atomicd oping has garnereds ome success in tuning the electronic properties and harnessing the vast potentialt hat TMDs can offer in the catalysis of the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER). Moreover,w ith computational studies reporting the promisinge ffects of transition-metal doping, such as trategy has been adopted with much enthusiasm.H erein, we consider one of the most prevalent TMDs, that is, MoS 2 ,a nd the possible presence of impurities arising from its preparation method and starting materials that may act as dopantst oa ffect its electronic and catalytic properties. An ultrapure MoS 2 material was synthesized and compared with ar elatively impure MoS 2 sample obtained commercially.U ltrapure MoS 2 was found to outperform its impurities-doped counterpart in HER catalysis. These findings not only providev aluable insighti nto the influence of parts-per-million concentrations of impuritieso nt he catalytic activity of TMD materials but also highlight the importance of the intentionala nd properd esign of atomicd oping to realize its true effects. At the same time, the need for am ore in-depth understanding and evaluation of the benefits of the atomic-doping strategy in the experimental setting as am eanst oh arnesst he potentialo fT MDs as catalystsf or hydrogen evolutionisa lso revealed.Transition-metal dichalcogenides (TMDs) have been placed in the spotlight for their layered structure, which is akin to that of graphite. Large variations in the band gaps of TMD materials confer aw ide spectrum of electronic properties ranging from insulating to metallic. [1, 2] For this reason, they have been extensively explored for applications such as energy storagea nd conversion, [3,4] lubrication, [5] sensing, [6,7] and catalysis. [8,9] Of par-ticulari nterest is their outstanding catalytic activity towards the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER), which could support the generation of hydrogen at high efficiencies and low costs in comparison to preciousPt-based catalysts. [10][11][12] To harnesst he vast potentialt hat TMDs can offer in HER catalysis,s ignificant effort has been directed to alteringt he structure and electronic properties of TMD materials. One of the strategies employed is atomicd oping, for which dopant atoms can directly substitute the atoms in the lattice or in the interstitial sites between atoms in the crystal lattice.M oreover,i ti s also possible for dopant atoms to intercalate between layers in the context of TMDs. [13] Hitherto, the strategy of atomic doping has garnered some successi ne nhancingt he catalytic activity of TMDs in the HER. Specifically,p revious reports on MoS 2 doped with vanadium, [14] rhenium, [15] and cobalt [16] resulted in higherHER efficiencies. Computational studies also determined the potential positivee ffects on the HER cat...