Meta-Analysis Using NGS Data: The Veillonella Species in Dental Caries

Abstract

Objectives: In light of recent technological advances in Next-generation sequencing (NGS) and the accumulation of large, publicly available oral microbiome datasets, the need for meta-analysing data on caries microbiome is becoming feasible and essential. A consensus on the identification of enriched organisms in cariogenic dysbiotic biofilms would be reached. For example, members of the Veillonella genus have been detected in caries biofilms, and may have an underestimated contribution to the dysbiotic process. Hence, we aimed to determine the abundance of Veillonella species in dental caries in studies using NGS data.Materials and Methods: Analysis was performed according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis (registered at PROSPERO: CRD42020204150). Studies investigating microbial composition in saliva, dental biofilm, or carious dentin were included. Six databases and grey literature were searched. Two independent reviewers selected the papers and assessed the methodological quality.Results: Searches retrieved 1,323 titles, from which 38 studies were included in a qualitative synthesis, comprising a total of 1,374 caries and 745 caries-free individuals. Most studies analysed 16S rRNA amplicons, and only 5 studies used shotgun metagenomics and metatranscriptomics. A geographical bias was observed. The methodological quality was downrated in 81.5% of the studies due to the lack of criteria for defining cases and standard criteria used for measurement of the condition in a reliable way. Six studies on early childhood caries (ECC) were meta-analysed, confirming a significant enrichment of Veillonella spp. in caries-associated biofilms (but not saliva) when compared to caries-free controls [mean difference: 2.22 (0.54–3.90); p = 0.01].Conclusions:Veillonella spp. is more abundant in individuals suffering with ECC when compared to caries-free controls (very low evidence certainty), and should be considered for further studies to observe their metabolism in dental caries. There is an urgent need for a consensus in methodologies used to allow for more rigorous comparison between NGS studies, particularly including clinical data and details of caries diagnosis, as they are currently scarce. Inconsistent reporting on the NGS data affected the cross-study comparison and the biological connexions of the relative abundances on caries microbiome.

High-Throughput Sequencing of Oral Microbiota in Candida Carriage Sjögren’s Syndrome Patients: A Pilot Cross-Sectional Study

“…At the species level, the significantly increasing abundance of V. parvula (OTU001) in SS patients than controls was observed in this present study. The presence of Veillonella in the salivary microbiota has been related to the occurrence of dental caries [ 47 ]. Veillonella is a gram-negative anaerobic coccus capable of fermenting organic acids such as malate and lactate.…”

Enrichment of sulphate-reducers and depletion of butyrate-producers may be hyperglycaemia signatures in the diabetic oral microbiome

“…Members of this genus are linked to the classical Socransky’s purple-complex [ 53 ], and their lactate metabolism might facilitate the pH neutralization in biofilms [ 54 ]. They have been already related to hyperglycaemia elsewhere [ 55 ] and dental caries [ 56 ]. These characteristics might explain the significant higher proportions of these organisms in lower pH environments.…”

The impact of Er:YAG laser combined with fluoride treatment on the supragingival plaque microbiome in children with multiple caries: a dynamic study

“…Fusobacterium is a strictly anaerobic Gram-negative bacillus, among which only a small number of strains are known to weakly ferment glucose and fructose [ 40 ]. Notably, Veillonella is more closely related to the dental pulp or periapical infection [ 41 , 42 ]. A positive correlation between Veillonella abundance and the occurrence of caries has been indicated [ 43 ].…”