Mentor and peer support for early career researchers sharing research with academia and beyond

Abstract

There is a growing expectation that doctoral candidates and early career academics publish research outputs such as journal articles and conference papers, and that they share their findings with key stakeholders beyond academia. However, it is not known if these expectations are being coupled with support from mentors and peers within institutions. Through interviews with recent PhD graduates working as early career researchers in Australia and Japan, this paper investigates if mentor and peer support for producing both academic and translational outputs was forthcoming during their doctoral candidature and beyond. It also investigates kinds of supports provided in doctoral candidature and early career. Thirty early career researchers in Australia and Japan took part in this qualitative study involving in-depth semi-structured interviews with a purposive sample of respondents. Researchers made translation support available for Japanese respondents so that those with limited English could take part. Findings suggest that mentor and peer support were not universal, and some respondents did not have a mentor or significant peer influence supporting their production of academic or translational research outputs. Support for sharing research with audiences beyond academia could be limited, with production of outputs for academic audiences consistently a greater focus of support. There were no mentoring supports for translational outputs that had salience across Australia and Japan within the sample. While limited attention has been given to the role that peer influence may play in supporting research output production of early career researchers the more even power relationship between peers as opposed to the peer-/mentor dyad can allow unique supports to flourish. Where institutions expect growing and diverse research output production by doctoral candidates and early career researchers, they should also ensure that support is provided through facilitating mentoring and peer relationships.

Women's career in Vietnamese academia: An analysis from multiple lenses

“…The benefits of peer support have been confirmed by various studies in academic settings (Bayfield, Colebrooke, Pitt, Pugh, & Stutter, 2020;S. Lee, 2017;Merga & Mason, 2021; T. V.…”

Producción Científica de los Asesores de Tesis de las Facultades de Medicina Humana en el Perú

“…Esto podría deberse a que el mayor número de publicaciones podría ser generado por parte de los estudiantes 24 . Entre los asesores con más publicaciones en Scopus encontramos que cinco eran asesores de la Universidad Peruana de Ciencias Aplicadas (UPC), lo cual hace referencia a su posición en el primer cuartil al igual que Universidad Peruana Cayetano Heredia (UPCH) y la Universidad Nacional Mayor de San Marcos (UNMSM), a su vez, los asesores con más publicaciones en Google Académico también pertenecían al grupo de universidades en el primer cuartil, quedando claro la importancia que podrían tener los asesores de investigación para la producción científica de una universidad 25,26 . Encontramos el caso especial del asesor Jhony A.…”

The Effectiveness of Induction of Novice Academics at Kwame Nkrumah University in Zambia

“…The above results show that novice academics are not properly guided in the new environment, but are left to discover things on their own. This trend exposes novice academics to anticipated failures that can be avoided and counters the notion of Merga & Mason (2021) who postulate that there is a need to foster some aspect of peer support among the early academicians by engaging seasoned academics to assume the role of mentors to eradicate deficiency of expertise in higher learning institutions. It can be argued that the lack of induction and mentorship of new academics in designing assessments and preparation of endof-year and final examination papers is chaotic because they can be a haven for producing half-baked teachers as well as reducing the ranking of the institution.…”

“…It can be argued that most of the universities in Zambia, including Kwame Nkrumah have very few seasoned academics who can assume the role of mentors (Masaiti et al, 2023). It is against this background of deficiency of expertise in higher education that there is a need to foster some aspect of peer support among early academicians (Merga & Mason, 2021). The above idea is meant to promote academic growth and sustainability of the new academic members of staff in higher learning institutions in the world and Zambia, in general, and Kwame Nkrumah University, in particular, and possibly most of Africa.…”