Mental health and the media: From illness to wellbeing

Abstract

The media are a main source of information about mental health for many people, and an ever‐growing body of literature is evaluating their coverage of the topic. To help keep track of such research, several comprehensive but now dated literature reviews have been published. We assess more recent studies (2007–2017) and suggest future directions by integrating (a) the “circuit of mass communication” model from media and communication studies which posits that production, content, and reception need to be analysed for an in‐depth understanding of the media, (b) the holistic view of mental health as comprising both illness and wellbeing, and (3) the critical psychiatry literature questioning the assumptions underlying psychiatric knowledge and practice. We find that recent studies have focused on content and “the illness side” of mental health by examining the representation of particular mental disorders and events involving individuals with specific diagnoses. We identify as a promising development the growing interest in “the wellbeing side” of mental health whereby authors have started to analyse recovery messages. We invite more production and reception research and more critical content studies which use diagnostic labels cautiously and analyse the representation of people with mental health problems as the victims of violence.

Exploring perceptions of positive mental health in young adults with intellectual disabilities

“…Additionally, such confusion may also reflect society at large. As the term mental health has been increasingly used in media, it has often been used to depict instances of mental health issues rather than the spectrum of mental health or positive mental health (Atanasova et al, 2019). This is consistent with the uncertainty they expressed about positive mental health, sometimes relying more on an illness-based understanding.…”

Mental Health and Stand-up Comedy: ‘Unhappy’ Stand-up Comedy as a Reflection of Liquid Modernity

“…For this study, a thematic analysis of the shows Shadows, Going Downhill and Look at You has been attempted using Zygmunt Bauman's theory of liquid modernity. Several studies examine the personality traits of artists and the representation of mental health in literature and media using theories on psychology or communication (Atanasova et. al, 2019).…”

Journalism and pedophilia: Background on the media coverage of a stigmatized minority.

“…Media coverage of mental health issues may either reinforce existing stigma or contribute to destigmatization (Atanasova et al, 2019; Goepfert et al, 2019; Sampogna et al, 2017; Sieff, 2003). Aragonès et al (2014) found in analyzing Spanish newspapers that 49% of the news items concerning mental issues linked mental disorders to danger like violent crimes which increases the perception of those affected as a threat.…”