Ras plays a central role in cell signaling pathways that control cell proliferation, differentiation, and metabolism (1-3). The signal is transmitted by the Ras-GTP complex, and hydrolysis of GTP to GDP turns the signal off. The intrinsic GTP hydrolysis rate is rather low, and it is greatly enhanced by GTPase-activating proteins. Numerous studies have been devoted to the mechanism of GTP hydrolysis by Ras in the presence or absence of GTPase-activating protein. Despite extensive structural, kinetic, and site-directed mutagenesis data, no consensus regarding key mechanistic aspects of catalysis by Ras has thus far been reached (4).Much of the debate has recently centered on the nature of the transition state for GTP hydrolysis (4, 5). The transition states for phosphoryl transfer reactions, which ATP and GTP hydrolysis are examples of, are usually described by a structure somewhere between dissociative and associative extremes (6). In the fully dissociative mechanism, reactions proceed via a metaphosphate intermediate, which is subsequently attacked by the nucleophile. In contrast, a fully associative mechanism involves a trigonal bipyramidal intermediate, followed by the departure of the leaving group. Between these two limits exist concerted pathways featuring trigonal bipyramidal transition states with no distinct intermediate. For GTP hydrolysis by Ras, several distinct models have been developed to explain the biochemical and mutagenesis data (4,5,7,8). While some groups have been looking for a general base that activates the water molecule in the active site to render it a better nucleophile (8 -10), others emphasized the contribution from transition state stabilization by Ras (7, 11). An underlying feature common to these models is the assumption that the transition state of the GTP hydrolysis is associative in nature. It is based on the observation that the ␥-phosphoryl group is surrounded by positive charges capable of neutralizing the negative charges accumulating on the ␥-phosphoryl oxygens in an associative transition state (7,(12)(13)(14). Evidence supporting an associative mechanism includes the following: (i) an observed linear free energy relationship between the rates of GTP hydrolysis by Ras mutants and the pK a values of the ␥-PO 3 2Ϫ group of GTP bound to these mutants (5); (ii) the observation that the catalytically important residues interact extensively with the transition state analog GDP-AlF 4 Ϫ in the crystal structures of Ras-GDP-AlF 4 Ϫ -GTPase-activating protein (15), G i␣1 -GDP-AlF 4 Ϫ (16), and transducin ␣-GDP-AlF 4 Ϫ (17). This assumption has been strongly challenged by Maegley et al. (4), who argued that the transition state is more likely dissociative in nature based on the following: (i) a wealth of physical organic data that implicates a dissociative, metaphosphate-like transition state in solution reactions of phosphate monoesters, acyl phosphates, phosphorylated amines (6), and phosphoanhydride (18); and (ii) the fact that the localization of positively charged side chains a...