Borides
containing 4d or 5d transition metals are among the most
common types of high hardness materials because of the high valence
electron density of the metals combined with short, covalent main
group bonding. Unfortunately, even though these compounds have outstanding
mechanical properties, most 4d and 5d transition metals are expensive
with low natural availability. Studying their 3d counterparts such
as Cr3B4 which has an experimentally measured
Vickers hardness of 26 GPa, may provide insight on the structure–property
relationship that can be used to develop earth-abundant, 3d transition
metal based high hardness materials. The origin of the mechanical
properties in Cr3B4 was therefore computationally
investigated using density functional theory. The changes in bonding
as a function of composition were analyzed through crystal orbital
Hamilton population calculations and revealed that the bonding in
Cr3B4 could be optimized by changing the valence
electron count via vanadium substitution. The calculations also verify
that as the bonding states are optimized, the mechanical properties
are improved. Further influencing the bonding by introducing Ti across
the hypothetical “V3–x
Ti
x
B4” solid solution shows
significant deterioration of the mechanical properties as the occupied
bonding states are depleted. These results prove the relationship
between bonding and intrinsic mechanical properties and indicate that
bonding optimization through elemental substitution is an effective
approach to tailor the properties of structural materials.