Measuring the Long-Term Effects of Public Policy: The Case of Narcotics Use and Property Crime

Abstract

The effects of treatment and legal supervision on narcotics use and criminal activities were assessed by applying newly developed time-series methods that disentangle the long-term (permanent) and the short-term (temporary) effects of intervention. A multivariate systems approach was used to characterize the dynamic interplay of several related behaviors at a group level over a long period of time. Five variables---abstinence from narcotics use, daily narcotics use (or addiction), property crime, methadone maintenance treatment, and legal supervision---were derived by aggregating information from over 600 narcotic addiction histories averaging 12 years in length. Because of the long assessment period, age was also included as a control variable. Overall, the system dynamics among the variables were characterized by long-term rather than short-term relationships. Neither methadone maintenance nor legal supervision had short-term effects on narcotics use or property crime. Methadone maintenance treatment demonstrated long-term benefits by reducing narcotics use and criminal activities. Legal supervision, on the other hand, did not reduce either narcotics use or property crime in the long run. Instead, there was a positive long-term relationship in which a higher level of legal supervision was related to higher levels of narcotics use and criminal activity. This latter finding is consistent with the observation that either narcotics use or criminal activity is likely to bring addicts to the attention of the legal system. However, these addicts, as a group, did not directly respond to legal supervision by changing their narcotics use or crime involvement except perhaps through coerced treatment. The paper explores the policy implications of these findings.public policy effectiveness, narcotics use, time series analysis, permanent and temporary effects, unit roots

Opiates, Criminal Behaviour, and Methadone Treatment

“…Even if expenditure on street drugs is not completely prevented by access to methadone, the results from the criminal earnings regression model imply that modest reductions in expenditures could still lead to a sizable reduction in income generated through criminal activity. This is consistent with existing evidence on treatment effectiveness with respect to criminal behaviour (Hubbard et al, 1989;Farrell et al, 1994;Gerstein et al, 1994;Powers et al, 1991;Kirby, 1996, Healey et al, 1999). Thus from a broader social perspective, methadone treatment services appear to offer a potentially viable policy option.…”

Off-label use of the expensive orphan drug eculizumab in France 2009–2013 and the impact of literature: focus on the transplantation field

“…For the analytical evaluation of the impact of publications on eculizumab dispensation, we used a two-step approach [19].…”

Who Benefits from Store Brand Entry?

“…VARX models are specified in levels, differences, or error-correction format, depending on the results of the unit-root and cointegration tests (Powers et al 1991). If all series are level or trend stationary, we formulate the following model in a category with three brands:…”